Peyton Cards
60 cards with graded values and live listings.
Browse every Peyton card tracked by HoodCar below. The floor currently tracks 60 graded Peyton cards ranging from $450 to $1,972. Each links to its full page with live pricing across PSA, BGS, SGC and CGC, refreshed every 6 hours. Prices reflect current eBay asking prices, not confirmed sales.
2008 UD Heroes Peyton Manning Auto Gold /25 PSA 10 Colts
$1,972
1998 Topps Chrome - Peyton Manning #165 (RC) - PSA 10
$1,850
1998 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning Refractor RC #1 PSA 9 MINT HOF Colts Football
$1,499
1998 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning RC #165 PSA 10 💎
$1,450
PEYTON MANNING PSA 9 1999 SKYBOX PREMIUM #8 2000 MEN 46/100 COLTS
$1,450
1998 Topps Draft Picks Peyton Manning RC #360 Colts PSA 10 Gem Mint Colts
$1,395
PSA 10 GEM 1998 Score Pre-Production PEYTON MANNING Artist's Proof RC Rookie
$1,300
1998 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning Refractor RC #1 PSA 9 MINT HOF Colts Football
$1,249
1998 Skybox E-X2001 PEYTON MANNING Rookie #1 Destination Honolulu PSA 6 SSP
$1,230
1998 Skybox E-X2001 Peyton Manning RC Rookie #1 Destination Honolulu PSA 6 SSP
$1,189
1998 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning #1 Rookie Card PSA Auto 10 RC Colts HOF 🔥
$1,095
Rare Peyton Manning Rookie Destination Honolulu SSP 1998 Skybox E-X2001 RC PSA 8
$1,090
1998 Skybox E-X2001 Peyton Manning RC Rookie #1 Destination Honolulu PSA 6 SSP
$1,087
2025 Panini Silhouette Case Hit Peyton Manning White Night 🔥🔥🔥 PSA 9 Pop 1
$1,000
PEYTON MANNING #16 SIGNED TENNESSEE VOLUNTEERS MITCHELL & NESS JERSEY PSA/DNA
$1000
1999 Skybox Premium Peyton Manning 2000 Men /100 PSA 6
$1000
PEYTON MANNING #16 SIGNED TENNESSEE VOLUNTEERS MITCHELL & NESS JERSEY PSA/DNA
$1000
2022 Flawless Peyton Manning Player Worn Patch-Auto PSA 8/PSA 9!!!🔥
$975
2021 Peyton Manning Downtown - PSA 9 - Mint Condition
$911
2022 Panini Prizm Peyton Manning Sensational Signatures Purple Power #2/5 PSA 10
$900
2021 Donruss Peyton Manning Downtown PSA 9 Mint SSP SP RARE POP 72 Colts HOF
$900
Topps Chrome 1998 Draft Picks Peyton Manning Colts #165 RC PSA 9 Card
$850
2021 Panini Donruss Optic Peyton Manning DOWNTOWN PSA 9 Mint Colts DT18 LOW POP!
$800
2023 Panini Donruss Peyton Manning Downtown Denver Broncos #9 PSA 10 Gem Mint
$800
2025 Panini Prizm Black - Peyton Manning #71 Gold Prizm /10
$800
2002 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Black Refractor /599 PSA 9 Mint
$800
2023 Panini Donruss Football Downtown #D9 Peyton Manning PSA 10 GEM SSP
$799
1998 Fleer Brilliants - Blue #120B Peyton Manning (RC) PSA 10
$750
PSA 10 Gem Mint Rc Peyton Manning Rookie 1998 Skybox E-X 2001 Stardate 2001 #15
$750
PEYTON MANNING 1998 Topps Finest REFRACTOR RC ROOKIE PSA 9
$749
1998 Topps #360 Peyton Manning RC GEM-MT PSA 10 Indianapolis Colts 4301
$725
1998 SKYBOX E-X2001 STARDATE 2001 #15 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 10
$722
1998 Skybox E-X2001 Peyton Manning Star Date 2001 PSA 10 Gem Mint RC Rookie HOF
$700
1 OF 1 Peyton Manning 2022 Donruss Clearly Retro 02-Holo Platinum 1/1 PSA MINT 9
$700
2022 Select Peyton Manning Color Wheel Gold /10 PSA 10
$690
2021 Panini Donruss Optic PEYTON MANNING Downtown! PSA 9 Indianapolis Colts
$675
1998 Topps Chrome - Peyton Manning #165 (RC) PSA 9
$650
1998 TOPPS CHROME #165 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC CARD INDIANAPOLIS COLTS PSA 9
$650
2003 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Colts #45 Black Refractor 599/599 PSA 9 bookend
$600
1998 Topps Action Flats Peyton Manning #K5 PSA 10
$575
2000 Topps Gallery of Heroes Peyton Manning #GH5 Stained Glass PSA 10
$550
2007 UD Trilogy Peyton Manning Signature Present /33 PSA 9/10 #PRSPM #SSP POP 3
$550
1999 Fleer Flair Showcase Peyton Manning Legacy Row 3 #/99 PSA 8 COLTS
$549
2003 SP Authentic - Sign of the Times Peyton Manning Auto #PM /900 PSA 10/10
$542
1998 FINEST W/COATING #121 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 10
$500
1998 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning #1 PSA 10
$500
1999 TOPPS CHROME REFRACTOR #120 PEYTON MANNING PSA 9
$500
Peyton Manning All-Etch Refractor - 1999 Topps Chrome #AE19 - PSA 10 (POP: 34)
$500
1998 Playoff Prestige Best of the NFL Non Die-Cut Peyton Manning RC PSA 9 Pop 1
$500
1999 Bowman's Best Peyton Manning Refractor #70 PSA 9 /400
$489
Upper Deck 2006 SPx Super Scripts Peyton Manning Colts Auto SS-PM /50 BGS 9.5
$484
Peyton Manning / Autographed Denver Broncos M&N Pro-Style Football Jersey / PSA
$480
2021 Prizm Draft Picks Peyton Manning PSA 10 On Campus #OCPM
$464
vintage PSA 10 - SUPER BOWL XLI COLTS vs BEARS FULL TICKET - PEYTON MANNING MVP
$459
Peyton Manning 2024 Topps Chrome Auto Gold Wave Refractor #/50 PSA 10 GEM POP 7
$455
1999 Topps Chrome - Peyton Manning #AE19 All Etch Refractor PSA 10 Gem Mint
$455
PEYTON MANNING #BCP1 1998 BOWMAN CHROME PREVIEW | REFRACTOR ROOKIE
$450
2014 Topps Five Star Peyton Manning Autographs Rainbow PSA 9
$450
2025 Peyton Manning Panini Silhouette White Night Case Hit SSP PSA 9
$450
Peyton Manning Signed Indianapolis Colts Jersey Autographed PERSONALIZED PSA/DNA
$450