Live Auction Floor — 710 Graded Cards

PSA 9

Peyton Manning PSA 10 Low Pop 2022 Panini Donruss 57 Indianapolis Colts NFL Card

$50

View on eBay

2017 Immaculate - Game Worn! Dual Jerseys Peyton Manning Andrew Luck 21/25!

$89

View on eBay

PSA 9

2005 Upper Deck Rookie Debut Peyton Manning Game Worn Patch Pop 5 PSA 9

$50

View on eBay

PSA 10

2002 LEAF CERTIFIED SKILLS FOOTBALL CARD #CS-4 HOF PEYTON MANNING PSA 10 POP 1

$67

View on eBay

PSA 10

1999 Topps Finest Peyton Manning Prominent Figures /5084 #PF6 PSA 10 Colts

$250

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

PSA 9

1998 TOPPS CHROME #165 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC CARD INDIANAPOLIS COLTS PSA 9

$650

View on eBay

PSA 9

1998 Topps Peyton Manning Football NFL Indianapolis Colts RC Card #360 PSA 9

$185

View on eBay

1998 Flair Showcase Row 1 Peyton Manning #3 PSA 7

$169

View on eBay

PSA 8

Peyton Manning Rookie PSA 8 Graded 1998 Metal Universe #189

$37

View on eBay

PSA 9

1999 Flair Showcase #70 PEYTON MANNING PSA 9 Mint Colts 🔥

$47

View on eBay

PEYTON MANNING~1998 ROOKIE PLAYOFF CONTENDERS LEATHER PSA-10 GEM-MT RC CARD #37

$300

View on eBay

Peyton Manning Signed 5x7 Photo Indianapolis Colts Autographed PSA/DNA COA

$175

View on eBay

PSA 9

1999 Donruss Preferred PEYTON MANNING X-Ponential Power INSERT /2500 PSA 9 HOF

$150

View on eBay

$2002 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Black Refractor /599 PSA 9 Mint$

PSA 9

2002 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Black Refractor /599 PSA 9 Mint

$800

View on eBay

PSA 10

Peyton Manning - 1998 Topps Finest RC #121 - Colts Rookie HOF GEM MINT - PSA 10

$225

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

PSA 10

1998 Collector’s Edge 1st Place Peyton Manning PSA 10 Gem Mint

$119

View on eBay

PSA 10

2014 SP AUTHENTIC #134 PEYTON MANNING BRONCOS HOF PSA 10

$40

View on eBay

PSA 9

1998 Topps Peyton Manning #360 (RC) - PSA 9 MINT 🔥🔥🔥 - Indianapolis Colts

$229

View on eBay

PSA 9

2022 Flawless Peyton Manning Player Worn Patch-Auto PSA 8/PSA 9!!!🔥

$975

View on eBay

PSA 10

2003 Topps Peyton Manning #HM8 Hobby Masters PSA 10 GEM MINT HOF Pop 6

$350

View on eBay

Peyton Manning 2025 Leaf Metal #P-PM2 Patriotic Auto 1/1

$140

View on eBay

PSA 10

2023 Panini Donruss Optic Downtown! #D9 Peyton Manning PSA 10

$1,100

View on eBay

PSA 9

Peyton Manning Nico Iamaleava 2024 Wild Card Green Rainbow Foil 1/1 PSA 9 Mint

$89

View on eBay

PSA 10

Peyton Manning 2017 Panini Certified #CC-PM Certified Champions PSA 10 Colts

$100

View on eBay

Vintage 1998 Bowman Football Peyton Manning #1 Rookie Card PSA Graded NM 7

$75

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

2024 Leaf Gold Prizm 1/1 GU Patch Tom Brady Peyton Manning Joe Montana 8.5 BGS

$1,499

View on eBay

2026 Wild Card National - Peyton Manning - Graffiti Matte Metal Auto True 1/1

$400

View on eBay

PSA 10

2014 Topps Finest Peyton Manning #50 PSA 10 Gem Mint

$50

View on eBay

2023 Flawless Peyton Manning Diamond Gem Legends - Platinum 1/1 - PSA

$1,199

View on eBay

2025 LEAF FLASH FLASHBACK PRISMATIC 1/1 AUTO PEYTON MANNING DENVER BRONCOS HOF ⭐

$200

View on eBay

PSA 9

2022 Panini Flawless Collegiate Peyton Manning Patch Auto /25 PSA 9 RARE

$825

View on eBay

2025 Eclectic Signatures Peyton Manning Pure Silver Prismatic Auto 1/1 PSA 7 NM

$249

View on eBay

PSA 10

2022 Select Peyton Watson Rookie Signature Gold Auto /10 RC #RSPYW PSA 10 -POP 1

$950

View on eBay

PSA 9

2007 UD Trilogy Peyton Manning Signature Present /33 PSA 9/10 #PRSPM #SSP POP 3

$550

View on eBay

$Topps 1999 Bowman's Best Peyton Manning #70 Refractor /400 Colts PSA 9 POP 32$

PSA 9

Topps 1999 Bowman's Best Peyton Manning #70 Refractor /400 Colts PSA 9 POP 32

$740

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

$1998 Peyton Manning Topps Finest Undergrads Refractor W/ Coating PSA 7 U20 RC$

1998 Peyton Manning Topps Finest Undergrads Refractor W/ Coating PSA 7 U20 RC

$350

View on eBay

$2008 Topps Letterman - Peyton Manning #3 Refractor 61/99 PSA 8$

PSA 8

2008 Topps Letterman - Peyton Manning #3 Refractor 61/99 PSA 8

$60

View on eBay

PSA 10

2012 Topps #350 PEYTON MANNING PSA 10 Gem Mint

$54

View on eBay

PSA 9

1998 Topps #360 Peyton Manning PSA 9 ROOKIE RC COLTS

$300

View on eBay

2002 Upper Deck American Authentics Peyton Manning Auto Colts PSA 7 Auto

$199

View on eBay

$1998 Bowman Chrome - Preview Peyton Manning #BCP1 Refractor (RC) PSA 8$

PSA 8

1998 Bowman Chrome - Preview Peyton Manning #BCP1 Refractor (RC) PSA 8

$850

View on eBay

PSA 10

PEYTON MANNING 2011 TOPPS LEGENDS FOOTBALL GOLD COLTS GEM /99 PSA 10 Q5775

$90

View on eBay

PSA 8

2003 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning #38 COLTS SP REFRACTOR /500 PSA 8

$285

View on eBay

PSA 9

PEYTON MANNING PSA 9 COLTS HOF QB REFRACTOR #1 2ND YEAR SP 1999 FINEST W/COATING

$450

View on eBay

$Peyton Manning 2009 Topps Chrome Blue Jersey Refractor PSA 9 Mint - READ$

PSA 9

Peyton Manning 2009 Topps Chrome Blue Jersey Refractor PSA 9 Mint - READ

$200

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

$Peyton Manning (RC) Grade PSA 7 - 1998 Bowman Chrome Refractor Rookie #BCP1$

Peyton Manning (RC) Grade PSA 7 - 1998 Bowman Chrome Refractor Rookie #BCP1

$580

View on eBay

PSA 9

PSA 9 1998 Topps 360 Peyton Manning Rookie RC

$300

View on eBay

1999 Collectors Edge Peyton Manning Masters Pro Signatures PSA AUTHENTIC #/500

$250

View on eBay

PSA 10

Joe Montana/Dan Marino/Peyton Manning 2024 LEAF Legends GRADED GEM-MT 10 #ELE-40

$30

View on eBay

PSA 9

2022 Panini Select - Field Level Peyton Manning #460 Blue Prizm /49 PSA 9 Mint

$90

View on eBay

PSA 10

1998 Press Pass — Kick-Off — Peyton Manning — ROOKIE — 💎 MINT PSA 10 — pop 137

$250

View on eBay

PSA 9

1998 Skybox E-X2001 Peyton Manning #54 Rookie Card PSA 9 Mint Colts HOF

$300

View on eBay

1998 Pacific Revolution Showstoppers #16 Peyton Manning Colts Rookie RC BGS 8

$35

View on eBay

PSA 10

2021 Mosaic Peyton Manning Genesis PSA 10 Only 23 PSA 10’s in Existence !!!!

$110

View on eBay

PSA 9

1999 Donruss Preferred PEYTON MANNING X-Ponential Power INSERT /2500 PSA 9 HOF

$115

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

Peyton Manning 2023 Leaf Magnificence GAME USED NUMBER PATCH AUTO 2/2 On-Card

$399

View on eBay

Peyton Watson rookie Patch Auto 2022-23 Immaculate Collection 88/99 nuggets cavs

$140

View on eBay

$1998 Bowman's Best Peyton Manning Refractor /200 #BP1 BGS 9.5 GEM MINT 183/200$

BGS 9.5

1998 Bowman's Best Peyton Manning Refractor /200 #BP1 BGS 9.5 GEM MINT 183/200

$2,200

View on eBay

1998 Bowman’s Best Best Performers #BP1 Peyton Manning ROOKIE PSA GEM MINT 10

$280

View on eBay

PSA 9

Topps 1998 Topps Chrome Draft Picks Peyton Manning #165 RC Base PSA 9

$550

View on eBay

PSA 9

1998 Fleer Brilliants Peyton Manning Blue Color Match Rookie RC PSA 9

$80

View on eBay

PSA 9

Topps 2005 Finest Peyton Manning Blue X-Fractor /150 #120 PSA 9 Colts

$470

View on eBay

PSA 10

1998 Collector's Edge Peyton Manning Promo Graded ROOKIE Card PSA 10 Collectors

$104

View on eBay

SGC 10

Panini 2021 Donruss Optic Peyton Manning Colts Downtown #DT-18 SGC 10

$1,300

View on eBay

Peyton Manning Pm-A UD Game Jersey

$350

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

PSA 10

💥 Peyton Manning PSA 10💥 1999 Topps - Season’s Best NEW CERT, LOW POP!!!

$1000

View on eBay

PSA 10

1989 Leaf Rookies & Stars Peyton Manning RC PSA 10 Gem Mint

$389

View on eBay

PSA 9

1998 Collector's Edge Peyton Manning Promo Graded ROOKIE Card PSA 9 Collectors

$35

View on eBay

PSA 10

2000 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning #112 Colts PSA 10 GEM MINT

$280

View on eBay

1998 Topps Action Flats - Peyton Manning #K5 (RC)

$750

View on eBay

2010 Panini Epix Peyton Manning Signed Auto PSA/DNA Authentic Colts HOF

$250

View on eBay

PSA 8

Fleer 2000 Fleer Focus Star Studded Peyton Manning #1 Colts PSA 8

$195

View on eBay

PSA 10

2007 TOPPS OWN THE GAME #PM2 PEYTON MANNING PSA 10

$140

View on eBay

$2013 Peyton Manning Bowman Silver Ice Refractor Graded PSA GEM MINT 10$

2013 Peyton Manning Bowman Silver Ice Refractor Graded PSA GEM MINT 10

$250

View on eBay

PSA 9

Peyton Manning Nico Iamaleava 2024 Wild Card Green Rainbow Foil 1/1 PSA 9 Mint

$89

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

2023 Panini Flawless Peyton Manning Colts AFC Champions Auto FP-PMA 15/25

$550

View on eBay

2005 Upper Deck ESPN SportsCenter Swatches Peyton Manning Game-Used Jersey Card

$20

View on eBay

2008 SPx Winning Materials WM-PM Peyton Manning Game-Used Jersey 050/149 HOF

$35

View on eBay

PSA 8

2015 Flawless Peyton Manning DeMarcus Ware Game Worn Patch /20 PSA 8 POP 1

$499

View on eBay

2004 UD SPX Peyton Manning Steve McNair Dual Auto Game Worn Patch PSA /25

$850

View on eBay

PSA 8

GAME USED WORN Peyton Manning/Smith 2005 UD Reflections Dual Jersey Card PSA 8

$100

View on eBay

PSA 10

2001 Pacific Private Stock #66 PEYTON MANNING Game Worn Patch /100 POP 1 PSA 10

$400

View on eBay

2010 Panini Peyton Manning GAME WORN PATCH Card#20 195 /299 (MEM)

$150

View on eBay

PSA 10

Peyton Manning PSA 10, pop 3, SSP / Topps Turkey Red, White #18 GOAT Hot Card

$224

View on eBay

PSA 9

Peyton Manning Topps Chrome 1998 Draft Picks #165 RC Indianapolis Colts PSA 9

$575

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

Peyton Manning Signed First Day Cover 2006 Touch Down Record Harrison PSA/DNA

$350

View on eBay

PSA 8

1998 Topps Stars Peyton Manning RC Red /8799 PSA 8 #67 Colts

$50

View on eBay

$Topps 2010 Finest Peyton Manning #80 Refractor Auto 21/99 Colts PSA 84336796$

PSA 8

Topps 2010 Finest Peyton Manning #80 Refractor Auto 21/99 Colts PSA 84336796

$400

View on eBay

PSA 9

Topps 1998 Topps Chrome Draft Picks Peyton Manning Colts #165 RC PSA 9

$550

View on eBay

PSA 10

Peyton Manning PSA 10 Low Pop 2013 Panini Contenders Football #14 Denver Broncos

$80

View on eBay

$1999 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Record Numbers Refractor #RN9 Colts PSA 7$

1999 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Record Numbers Refractor #RN9 Colts PSA 7

$300

View on eBay

PSA 8

1998 Ultra Peyton Manning #201 Rookie RC PSA 8

$35

View on eBay

PSA 10

2000 TOPPS CHROME #16 PEYTON MANNING PSA 10

$250

View on eBay

PSA 8

Fleer 1998 Ultra Peyton Manning Rookie #201 Indianapolis Colts PSA 8

$35

View on eBay

PSA 10

Graded 1998 Collector's Edge Peyton Manning #135 1st Place RC Card PSA 10

$235

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

Live Graded Cards

2025 Peyton Manning Panini Silhouette White Night Case Hit SSP PSA 9

1998 Collector’s Edge Peyton Manning Rc PSA/DNA - SUPER VALUE !!!!

PEYTON MANNING~1998 BOWMAN CHROME PSA-9 MINT HOT GRADED NFL ROOKIE RC CARD #1

1998 BOWMAN'S BEST #112 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 10

1998 Finest Stadium Stars #SS9 Peyton Manning RC-Rookie Colts graded PSA 7 NM

Peyton Manning PSA 10 Low Pop 2022 Panini Donruss 57 Indianapolis Colts NFL Card

2017 Immaculate - Game Worn! Dual Jerseys Peyton Manning Andrew Luck 21/25!

2005 Upper Deck Rookie Debut Peyton Manning Game Worn Patch Pop 5 PSA 9

2002 LEAF CERTIFIED SKILLS FOOTBALL CARD #CS-4 HOF PEYTON MANNING PSA 10 POP 1

1999 Topps Finest Peyton Manning Prominent Figures /5084 #PF6 PSA 10 Colts

1998 TOPPS CHROME #165 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC CARD INDIANAPOLIS COLTS PSA 9

1998 Topps Peyton Manning Football NFL Indianapolis Colts RC Card #360 PSA 9

1998 Flair Showcase Row 1 Peyton Manning #3 PSA 7

Peyton Manning Rookie PSA 8 Graded 1998 Metal Universe #189

1999 Flair Showcase #70 PEYTON MANNING PSA 9 Mint Colts 🔥

PEYTON MANNING~1998 ROOKIE PLAYOFF CONTENDERS LEATHER PSA-10 GEM-MT RC CARD #37

Peyton Manning Signed 5x7 Photo Indianapolis Colts Autographed PSA/DNA COA

1999 Donruss Preferred PEYTON MANNING X-Ponential Power INSERT /2500 PSA 9 HOF

2002 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Black Refractor /599 PSA 9 Mint

Peyton Manning - 1998 Topps Finest RC #121 - Colts Rookie HOF GEM MINT - PSA 10

1998 Collector’s Edge 1st Place Peyton Manning PSA 10 Gem Mint

2014 SP AUTHENTIC #134 PEYTON MANNING BRONCOS HOF PSA 10

1998 Topps Peyton Manning #360 (RC) - PSA 9 MINT 🔥🔥🔥 - Indianapolis Colts

2022 Flawless Peyton Manning Player Worn Patch-Auto PSA 8/PSA 9!!!🔥

2003 Topps Peyton Manning #HM8 Hobby Masters PSA 10 GEM MINT HOF Pop 6

Peyton Manning 2025 Leaf Metal #P-PM2 Patriotic Auto 1/1

2023 Panini Donruss Optic Downtown! #D9 Peyton Manning PSA 10

Peyton Manning Nico Iamaleava 2024 Wild Card Green Rainbow Foil 1/1 PSA 9 Mint

Peyton Manning 2017 Panini Certified #CC-PM Certified Champions PSA 10 Colts

Vintage 1998 Bowman Football Peyton Manning #1 Rookie Card PSA Graded NM 7

2024 Leaf Gold Prizm 1/1 GU Patch Tom Brady Peyton Manning Joe Montana 8.5 BGS

2026 Wild Card National - Peyton Manning - Graffiti Matte Metal Auto True 1/1

2014 Topps Finest Peyton Manning #50 PSA 10 Gem Mint

2023 Flawless Peyton Manning Diamond Gem Legends - Platinum 1/1 - PSA

2025 LEAF FLASH FLASHBACK PRISMATIC 1/1 AUTO PEYTON MANNING DENVER BRONCOS HOF ⭐

2022 Panini Flawless Collegiate Peyton Manning Patch Auto /25 PSA 9 RARE

2025 Eclectic Signatures Peyton Manning Pure Silver Prismatic Auto 1/1 PSA 7 NM

2022 Select Peyton Watson Rookie Signature Gold Auto /10 RC #RSPYW PSA 10 -POP 1

2007 UD Trilogy Peyton Manning Signature Present /33 PSA 9/10 #PRSPM #SSP POP 3

Topps 1999 Bowman's Best Peyton Manning #70 Refractor /400 Colts PSA 9 POP 32

1998 Peyton Manning Topps Finest Undergrads Refractor W/ Coating PSA 7 U20 RC

2008 Topps Letterman - Peyton Manning #3 Refractor 61/99 PSA 8

2012 Topps #350 PEYTON MANNING PSA 10 Gem Mint

1998 Topps #360 Peyton Manning PSA 9 ROOKIE RC COLTS

2002 Upper Deck American Authentics Peyton Manning Auto Colts PSA 7 Auto

1998 Bowman Chrome - Preview Peyton Manning #BCP1 Refractor (RC) PSA 8

PEYTON MANNING 2011 TOPPS LEGENDS FOOTBALL GOLD COLTS GEM /99 PSA 10 Q5775

2003 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning #38 COLTS SP REFRACTOR /500 PSA 8

PEYTON MANNING PSA 9 COLTS HOF QB REFRACTOR #1 2ND YEAR SP 1999 FINEST W/COATING

Peyton Manning 2009 Topps Chrome Blue Jersey Refractor PSA 9 Mint - READ

Peyton Manning (RC) Grade PSA 7 - 1998 Bowman Chrome Refractor Rookie #BCP1

PSA 9 1998 Topps 360 Peyton Manning Rookie RC

1999 Collectors Edge Peyton Manning Masters Pro Signatures PSA AUTHENTIC #/500

Joe Montana/Dan Marino/Peyton Manning 2024 LEAF Legends GRADED GEM-MT 10 #ELE-40

2022 Panini Select - Field Level Peyton Manning #460 Blue Prizm /49 PSA 9 Mint

1998 Press Pass — Kick-Off — Peyton Manning — ROOKIE — 💎 MINT PSA 10 — pop 137

1998 Skybox E-X2001 Peyton Manning #54 Rookie Card PSA 9 Mint Colts HOF

1998 Pacific Revolution Showstoppers #16 Peyton Manning Colts Rookie RC BGS 8

2021 Mosaic Peyton Manning Genesis PSA 10 Only 23 PSA 10’s in Existence !!!!

1999 Donruss Preferred PEYTON MANNING X-Ponential Power INSERT /2500 PSA 9 HOF

Peyton Manning 2023 Leaf Magnificence GAME USED NUMBER PATCH AUTO 2/2 On-Card

Peyton Watson rookie Patch Auto 2022-23 Immaculate Collection 88/99 nuggets cavs

1998 Bowman's Best Peyton Manning Refractor /200 #BP1 BGS 9.5 GEM MINT 183/200

1998 Bowman’s Best Best Performers #BP1 Peyton Manning ROOKIE PSA GEM MINT 10

Topps 1998 Topps Chrome Draft Picks Peyton Manning #165 RC Base PSA 9

1998 Fleer Brilliants Peyton Manning Blue Color Match Rookie RC PSA 9

Topps 2005 Finest Peyton Manning Blue X-Fractor /150 #120 PSA 9 Colts

1998 Collector's Edge Peyton Manning Promo Graded ROOKIE Card PSA 10 Collectors

Panini 2021 Donruss Optic Peyton Manning Colts Downtown #DT-18 SGC 10

Peyton Manning Pm-A UD Game Jersey

💥 Peyton Manning PSA 10💥 1999 Topps - Season’s Best *NEW CERT, LOW POP!!!*

1989 Leaf Rookies & Stars Peyton Manning RC PSA 10 Gem Mint

1998 Collector's Edge Peyton Manning Promo Graded ROOKIE Card PSA 9 Collectors

2000 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning #112 Colts PSA 10 GEM MINT

1998 Topps Action Flats - Peyton Manning #K5 (RC)

2010 Panini Epix Peyton Manning Signed Auto PSA/DNA Authentic Colts HOF

Fleer 2000 Fleer Focus Star Studded Peyton Manning #1 Colts PSA 8

2007 TOPPS OWN THE GAME #PM2 PEYTON MANNING PSA 10

2013 Peyton Manning Bowman Silver Ice Refractor Graded PSA GEM MINT 10

💥 Peyton Manning PSA 10💥 1999 Topps - Season’s Best NEW CERT, LOW POP!!!