Live Auction Floor — 710 Graded Cards

PSA 10

$2009 Bowman Chrome #12 Peyton Manning Xfractor /250 PSA 8$

PSA 8

2009 Bowman Chrome #12 Peyton Manning Xfractor /250 PSA 8

$98

View on eBay

PSA 9

2001 Topps Heritage #25 Peyton Manning PSA 9 MINT; Indianapolis Colts; HOF NFL

$25

View on eBay

PSA 9

2017 Panini Pantheon Metal #55 Peyton Manning /30 PSA 9 Colts

$103

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

1998 TOPPS CHROME #165 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 6

$69

View on eBay

PSA 9

Peyton Manning 2000 Collector's Edge Uncirculated PSA 9 #150 Indianapolis Colts

$17

View on eBay

1998 Upper Deck - NFL Star Rookie Peyton Manning #1 (RC) PSA 7

$26

View on eBay

1998 Score Peyton Manning 1/1 Rookie Auto BGS 8.5 Colts RC Autograph 1 of 1

$3,499

View on eBay

2019 Panini Flawless Peyton Manning Legends Platinum Diamond #1/1 One of One

$1000

View on eBay

$1999 Finest Peyton Manning Rookie Refractor PSA10 GEM #142$

1999 Finest Peyton Manning Rookie Refractor PSA10 GEM #142

$190

View on eBay

2006 TOPPS FOOTBALL #51 PEYTON MANNING BLACK BORDER COLTS RARE SP #28/51 PSA 7!

$299

View on eBay

PSA 10

2024 TOPPS CHROME PEYTON MANNING #H3 HELIX PSA 10

$175

View on eBay

PSA 9

1999 Flair Showcase #70 PEYTON MANNING PSA 9 Mint Colts

$43

View on eBay

2000 EX - E-Xceptional Peyton Manning #2 XC Green PSA Colts HOF

$40

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

PSA 8

2024 Topps Chrome Legends of the Gridiron Peyton Manning LOG-2 PSA 8

$10

View on eBay

PSA 10

1998 Collector's Edge Peyton Manning Promo Graded ROOKIE Card PSA 10 Collectors

$86

View on eBay

PSA 10

Peyton Manning PSA 10 Press Proof Premium 2021 Panini Donruss GEM MINT

$18

View on eBay

PSA 9

2005 Topps Chrome - Peyton Manning #136 PSA 9

$15

View on eBay

PSA 10

1998 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning RC #165 PSA 10 💎

$1,450

View on eBay

PSA 9

2000 Collector's Edge Graded - Peyton Manning #150 PSA 9

$16

View on eBay

PSA 10

1998 Topps Gold Label - Peyton Manning #20 Class 1 (RC) PSA 10 Gem MINT Card

$320

View on eBay

$1999 Bowman's Best Peyton Manning Refractor #70 PSA 9 /400$

PSA 9

1999 Bowman's Best Peyton Manning Refractor #70 PSA 9 /400

$175

View on eBay

PSA 10

1998 BOWMAN #1 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 10

$260

View on eBay

PSA 9

1998 Topps Peyton Manning Rookie - PSA 9 - #360

$100

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

PSA 9

1998 Upper Deck Black Diamond Rookies Single - PEYTON MANNING - PSA 9 Mint (RC)

$79

View on eBay

BGS 9.5

Upper Deck 2006 SPx Super Scripts Peyton Manning Colts Auto SS-PM /50 BGS 9.5

$484

View on eBay

PSA 9

2017 Panini Pantheon Metal #55 Peyton Manning /50 PSA 9 Colts

$103

View on eBay

PSA 9

1998 Bowman's Best Peyton Manning #112 (RC) - PSA 9 - Mint - Rookie Card

$49

View on eBay

PSA 10

2011 TOPPS #368 INDIANAPOLIS COLTS PEYTON MANNING PSA 10

$25

View on eBay

Peyton Manning Signed 5x7 Photo Indianapolis Colts Autographed PSA/DNA COA

$150

View on eBay

PSA 10

2003 SP Authentic - Sign of the Times Peyton Manning Auto #PM /900 PSA 10/10

$542

View on eBay

PSA 10

2016 Panini Prestige Peyton Manning Xtra Points Gold /50 #57 PSA GEM MT 10

$85

View on eBay

PSA 10

Peyton Manning 1998 Collector's Edge Odyssey Holding Jersey Promo RC PSA 10 HOF!

$100

View on eBay

PSA 8

1998 Upper Deck Encore #1 Peyton Manning PSA 8 Rookie RC Colts Broncos HOF

$70

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

PSA 9

PSA 9 1998 98 Bowman Chrome REFRACTOR Preview PEYTON MANNING RC Rookie #BCP1 REF

$385

View on eBay

PSA 10

2023 Panini Donruss Football Downtown #D9 Peyton Manning PSA 10 GEM SSP

$799

View on eBay

PSA 10

1998 Topps Finest - Rookie Peyton Manning #121 Rookie RC - PSA 10

$149

View on eBay

$Peyton Manning All-Etch Refractor - 1999 Topps Chrome #AE19 - PSA 10 (POP: 34)$

PSA 10

Peyton Manning All-Etch Refractor - 1999 Topps Chrome #AE19 - PSA 10 (POP: 34)

$500

View on eBay

PSA 10

PEYTON MANNING 2024 SELECT SUITE LEVEL COSMIC PRIZM REFRACTOR PSA 10 POP 3

$300

View on eBay

PSA 9

1998 Topps Finest Peyton Manning #121 Rookie Card RC Indianapolis Colts PSA 9

$60

View on eBay

PSA 9

1998 Topps Stars #67 Gold /1999 Peyton Manning RC PSA 9 Mint Rare Topps Rookie

$250

View on eBay

PSA 10

2008 UD Heroes Peyton Manning Auto Gold /25 PSA 10 Colts

$1,972

View on eBay

PSA 9

Collector's Edge 2000 Graded Peyton Manning #150 Uncirculated PSA 9 /5000 Colts

$16

View on eBay

PSA 9

1998 TOPPS CHROME #165 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 9

$199

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

1998 Topps Peyton Manning Rookie #360 Colts Rc

$37

View on eBay

Panini 2023 Immaculate Peyton Manning Broncos Immaculate Records Auto /25 IR-PMA

$300

View on eBay

Panini 2022 Black Capstones Peyton Manning CS-19 Platinum 1/1 Auto PSA Auth

$3,900

View on eBay

Leaf Metal Peyton Houston 1/1 Auto Prep School Signing Football Card 2025

$30

View on eBay

PEYTON MANNING AUTOGRAPHED 2001 Upper Deck UD MVP Souvenirs Game Ball Auto #1/25

$750

View on eBay

BGS 9

2024 Panini Spectra Spectral Signatures Neon Pink #1 Peyton Manning BGS 9.0

$400

View on eBay

PSA 9

2000 E-X E-Xceptional Peyton Manning Red PSA 9 Jambalaya Like Insert

$75

View on eBay

1999 Skybox Premium Peyton Manning 2000 Men /100 PSA 6

$1000

View on eBay

Bowman Autographed Rookie Peyton Manning #1 1998 PSA/DNA 133431536 Colts

$380

View on eBay

$2003 Topps Draft Picks/Pros Chrome #10 Peyton Manning Gold Refractor PSA 8$

PSA 8

2003 Topps Draft Picks/Pros Chrome #10 Peyton Manning Gold Refractor PSA 8

$40

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

$2013 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Refractor PSA 9 Broncos$

PSA 9

2013 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Refractor PSA 9 Broncos

$40

View on eBay

PSA 10

2024 Topps Cosmic Chrome Planetary Pursuit The Sun Peyton Manning PSA 10

$70

View on eBay

PSA 10

2016 Panini Prizm Blue Wave /149 Peyton Manning #125 PSA 10 GEM MT HOF READ 8uc

$85

View on eBay

$Peyton Manning 2024 Topps Chrome Auto Gold Wave Refractor #/50 PSA 10 GEM POP 7$

PSA 10

Peyton Manning 2024 Topps Chrome Auto Gold Wave Refractor #/50 PSA 10 GEM POP 7

$455

View on eBay

PSA 9

2011 TOPPS PLATINUM #100 PEYTON MANNING COLTS HOF PSA 9

$17

View on eBay

PSA 10

2000 Skybox Dominion #5 Peyton Manning PSA 10 Characteristics Colts

$200

View on eBay

PSA 10

1998 Skybox E-X2001 Peyton Manning Star Date 2001 PSA 10 Gem Mint RC Rookie HOF

$700

View on eBay

PSA 9

PEYTON MANNING 1998 Topps Finest REFRACTOR RC ROOKIE PSA 9

$749

View on eBay

PSA 9

2021 Panini Donruss Optic Peyton Manning DOWNTOWN PSA 9 Mint Colts DT18 LOW POP!

$800

View on eBay

PSA 9

2005 Topps Chrome #360 Peyton Manning PSA 9 Mint Anniversary Reprint Colts HOF

$150

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

PSA 9

2000 Collectors Edge Graded Peyton Manning Uncirculated PSA 9 Colts HOF /5000

$16

View on eBay

2003 FLEER PLATINUM ALMA MATERIALS PREP TO PRO #AMDPM PEYTON MANNING 3/200 PSA 7

$250

View on eBay

PSA 10

2005 Bowman's Best Bowman #2 Peyton Manning PSA 10

$75

View on eBay

PSA 9

2015 PANINI PRIZM BLUE PRIZM #18 PEYTON MANNING PSA 9

$50

View on eBay

PSA 8

1999 Donruss Preferred PEYTON MANNING Power /300 PSA 8

$92

View on eBay

BGS 9.5

2000 UD Pros & Prospects Peyton Manning Signature Game Used Jersey Auto BGS 9.5

$900

View on eBay

PSA 10

2022 Select Peyton Manning Color Wheel Gold /10 PSA 10

$690

View on eBay

PSA 9

Peyton Manning PSA 9 - 2003 Topps Chrome #RB22 RECORD BREAKERS-REFRACTOR /100

$419

View on eBay

PSA 10

2021 Prizm Draft Picks Peyton Manning PSA 10 On Campus #OCPM

$464

View on eBay

PSA 10

2005 BOWMAN CHROME FOOTBALL CARD #1 HOF PEYTON MANNING PSA 10 LOW POP NFL COLTS

$62

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

PSA 10

2012 Topps Peyton Manning #350 PSA 10 (137865317)

$35

View on eBay

$2006 Topps Finest #120 Peyton Manning Refractor /399 Colts HOF - PSA 9$

PSA 9

2006 Topps Finest #120 Peyton Manning Refractor /399 Colts HOF - PSA 9

$125

View on eBay

PSA 9

2024 TOPPS CHROME SAPPHIRE PURPLE #86 PEYTON MANNING 4/10 PSA 9

$80

View on eBay

PSA 9

1999 Topps Stars Peyton Manning Starcards 1 Star Rainbow /299 #23 PSA 9 SP Pop 1

$109

View on eBay

PSA 8

2001 Upper Deck SP Authentic Peyton Manning Sign of the Times #PM Auto PSA 8

$245

View on eBay

1998 Peyton Manning Upper Deck UD3 Future Shock Die Cut RC /2000 PSA 7

$75

View on eBay

PSA 8

1998 Topps #360 Peyton Manning Colts Rookie Card PSA 8 NM MT

$65

View on eBay

$2002 Bowman Chrome Xfractor #100 80/250 Peyton Manning PSA MINT 9 HOF$

2002 Bowman Chrome Xfractor #100 80/250 Peyton Manning PSA MINT 9 HOF

$200

View on eBay

PSA 10

Peyton Manning 2020 Panini Mosaic Montage Insert #M14 SP Mosaic Prizm PSA 10

$60

View on eBay

PSA 8

1999 Stadium Club 3X3 Peyton Manning #T4A PSA 8 Die Cut Colts

$30

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

PSA 10

2011 TOPPS #368 INDIANAPOLIS COLTS PEYTON MANNING PSA 10

$22

View on eBay

PSA 9

2025 Panini Silhouette Case Hit Peyton Manning White Night 🔥🔥🔥 PSA 9 Pop 1

$1,000

View on eBay

PSA 8

1998 Peyton Manning UD Super Powers Quantum Bronze Die Cut #S16 /100 PSA 8 RC

$400

View on eBay

PSA 8

2000 Topps Chrome #16 Peyton Manning PSA 8 Colts HOF

$15

View on eBay

2000 E-X E-Xceptional Peyton Manning Green Rare SGC 7 Jambalaya Like Insert

$45

View on eBay

PSA 9

1998 Upper Deck Peyton Manning Rookie Card #1 PSA 9 HOF RC Star Rookie

$76

View on eBay

PSA 10

2016 Prizm LIGHT BLUE SP PEYTON MANNING #/199 PSA 10 🔥

$109

View on eBay

PSA 9

1998 Bowman's Best Peyton Manning RC #112 PSA 9 MINT HOF

$50

View on eBay

PSA 9

1999 BOWMAN'S BEST REFRACTOR #95 PEYTON MANNING 380/400 PSA 9

$189

View on eBay

PSA 10

2006 Ultimate Collection #81 Peyton Manning /525 PSA 10 Gem Mint Colts

$98

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

Live Graded Cards

2013 PANINI SELECT PEYTON MANNING HOT STARS #12 BRONCOS HOF PSA 10 GEM MINT

2000 Collector's Edge Masters PEYTON MANNING #/2000 PSA 10

2008 Upper Deck Heroes Peyton Manning #79 Colts HOF PSA 10

1999 Stadium Club 3x3 Peyton Manning Illuminator #T4A PSA 10 POP 11 SSP 1:4320

Peyton Manning 1999 Upper Deck MVP #D10 Dynamics Indianapolis Colts PSA 9

2007 UltimateCollection Peyton Manning #UM-PE Silver /125 PSA 7

Peyton Manning (RC) Grade PSA 8 - 1998 Bowman Chrome Rookie #1

2009 Bowman Chrome #12 Peyton Manning Xfractor /250 PSA 8

2001 Topps Heritage #25 Peyton Manning PSA 9 MINT; Indianapolis Colts; HOF NFL

2017 Panini Pantheon Metal #55 Peyton Manning /30 PSA 9 Colts

1998 TOPPS CHROME #165 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 6

Peyton Manning 2000 Collector's Edge Uncirculated PSA 9 #150 Indianapolis Colts

1998 Upper Deck - NFL Star Rookie Peyton Manning #1 (RC) PSA 7

1998 Score Peyton Manning 1/1 Rookie Auto BGS 8.5 Colts RC Autograph 1 of 1

2019 Panini Flawless Peyton Manning Legends Platinum Diamond #1/1 One of One

1999 Finest Peyton Manning Rookie Refractor PSA10 GEM #142

2006 TOPPS FOOTBALL #51 PEYTON MANNING BLACK BORDER COLTS RARE SP #28/51 PSA 7!

2024 TOPPS CHROME PEYTON MANNING #H3 HELIX PSA 10

1999 Flair Showcase #70 PEYTON MANNING PSA 9 Mint Colts

2000 EX - E-Xceptional Peyton Manning #2 XC Green PSA Colts HOF

2024 Topps Chrome Legends of the Gridiron Peyton Manning LOG-2 PSA 8

1998 Collector's Edge Peyton Manning Promo Graded ROOKIE Card PSA 10 Collectors

Peyton Manning PSA 10 Press Proof Premium 2021 Panini Donruss GEM MINT

2005 Topps Chrome - Peyton Manning #136 PSA 9

1998 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning RC #165 PSA 10 💎

2000 Collector's Edge Graded - Peyton Manning #150 PSA 9

1998 Topps Gold Label - Peyton Manning #20 Class 1 (RC) PSA 10 Gem MINT Card

1999 Bowman's Best Peyton Manning Refractor #70 PSA 9 /400

1998 BOWMAN #1 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 10

1998 Topps Peyton Manning Rookie - PSA 9 - #360

1998 Upper Deck Black Diamond Rookies Single - PEYTON MANNING - PSA 9 Mint (RC)

Upper Deck 2006 SPx Super Scripts Peyton Manning Colts Auto SS-PM /50 BGS 9.5

2017 Panini Pantheon Metal #55 Peyton Manning /50 PSA 9 Colts

1998 Bowman's Best Peyton Manning #112 (RC) - PSA 9 - Mint - Rookie Card

2011 TOPPS #368 INDIANAPOLIS COLTS PEYTON MANNING PSA 10

Peyton Manning Signed 5x7 Photo Indianapolis Colts Autographed PSA/DNA COA

2003 SP Authentic - Sign of the Times Peyton Manning Auto #PM /900 PSA 10/10

2016 Panini Prestige Peyton Manning Xtra Points Gold /50 #57 PSA GEM MT 10

Peyton Manning 1998 Collector's Edge Odyssey Holding Jersey Promo RC PSA 10 HOF!

1998 Upper Deck Encore #1 Peyton Manning PSA 8 Rookie RC Colts Broncos HOF

PSA 9 1998 98 Bowman Chrome REFRACTOR Preview PEYTON MANNING RC Rookie #BCP1 REF

2023 Panini Donruss Football Downtown #D9 Peyton Manning PSA 10 GEM SSP

1998 Topps Finest - Rookie Peyton Manning #121 Rookie RC - PSA 10

Peyton Manning All-Etch Refractor - 1999 Topps Chrome #AE19 - PSA 10 (POP: 34)

PEYTON MANNING 2024 SELECT SUITE LEVEL COSMIC PRIZM REFRACTOR PSA 10 *POP 3*

1998 Topps Finest Peyton Manning #121 Rookie Card RC Indianapolis Colts PSA 9

1998 Topps Stars #67 Gold /1999 Peyton Manning RC PSA 9 Mint Rare Topps Rookie

2008 UD Heroes Peyton Manning Auto Gold /25 PSA 10 Colts

Collector's Edge 2000 Graded Peyton Manning #150 Uncirculated PSA 9 /5000 Colts

1998 TOPPS CHROME #165 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 9

1998 Topps Peyton Manning Rookie #360 Colts Rc

Panini 2023 Immaculate Peyton Manning Broncos Immaculate Records Auto /25 IR-PMA

Panini 2022 Black Capstones Peyton Manning CS-19 Platinum 1/1 Auto PSA Auth

Leaf Metal Peyton Houston 1/1 Auto Prep School Signing Football Card 2025

PEYTON MANNING AUTOGRAPHED 2001 Upper Deck UD MVP Souvenirs Game Ball Auto #1/25

2024 Panini Spectra Spectral Signatures Neon Pink #1 Peyton Manning BGS 9.0

2000 E-X E-Xceptional Peyton Manning Red PSA 9 Jambalaya Like Insert

1999 Skybox Premium Peyton Manning 2000 Men /100 PSA 6

Bowman Autographed Rookie Peyton Manning #1 1998 PSA/DNA 133431536 Colts

2003 Topps Draft Picks/Pros Chrome #10 Peyton Manning Gold Refractor PSA 8

2013 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Refractor PSA 9 Broncos

2024 Topps Cosmic Chrome Planetary Pursuit The Sun Peyton Manning PSA 10

2016 Panini Prizm Blue Wave /149 Peyton Manning #125 PSA 10 GEM MT HOF READ 8uc

Peyton Manning 2024 Topps Chrome Auto Gold Wave Refractor #/50 PSA 10 GEM POP 7

2011 TOPPS PLATINUM #100 PEYTON MANNING COLTS HOF PSA 9

2000 Skybox Dominion #5 Peyton Manning PSA 10 Characteristics Colts

1998 Skybox E-X2001 Peyton Manning Star Date 2001 PSA 10 Gem Mint RC Rookie HOF

PEYTON MANNING 1998 Topps Finest REFRACTOR RC ROOKIE PSA 9

2021 Panini Donruss Optic Peyton Manning DOWNTOWN PSA 9 Mint Colts DT18 LOW POP!

2005 Topps Chrome #360 Peyton Manning PSA 9 Mint Anniversary Reprint Colts HOF

2000 Collectors Edge Graded Peyton Manning Uncirculated PSA 9 Colts HOF /5000

2003 FLEER PLATINUM ALMA MATERIALS PREP TO PRO #AMDPM PEYTON MANNING 3/200 PSA 7

2005 Bowman's Best Bowman #2 Peyton Manning PSA 10

2015 PANINI PRIZM BLUE PRIZM #18 PEYTON MANNING PSA 9

1999 Donruss Preferred PEYTON MANNING Power /300 PSA 8

2000 UD Pros & Prospects Peyton Manning Signature Game Used Jersey Auto BGS 9.5

2022 Select Peyton Manning Color Wheel Gold /10 PSA 10

Peyton Manning PSA 9 - 2003 Topps Chrome #RB22 RECORD BREAKERS-REFRACTOR /100

2021 Prizm Draft Picks Peyton Manning PSA 10 On Campus #OCPM

PEYTON MANNING 2024 SELECT SUITE LEVEL COSMIC PRIZM REFRACTOR PSA 10 POP 3