Live Auction Floor — 710 Graded Cards

PSA 8

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

PSA 10

Peyton Manning 1999 Playoff Contenders Season Ticket 💎 PSA 10 💎 POP 9 💎 #104

$240

View on eBay

PSA 9

1998 Fleer Ultra Gold Medallion Peyton Manning Rookie #201G PSA 9

$320

View on eBay

PSA 9

1998 SKYBOX E-X2001 #54 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 9

$275

View on eBay

PSA 10

2006 Topps #288 Peyton Manning PSA 10 🏈 💥

$30

View on eBay

PSA 10

1998 Bowman Interstate Peyton Manning #1 Rookie RC HOF PSA 10

$685

View on eBay

$Topps 2007 Chrome Peyton Manning #TC5 Red Refractor /250 PSA 10 Colts$

PSA 10

Topps 2007 Chrome Peyton Manning #TC5 Red Refractor /250 PSA 10 Colts

$2,000

View on eBay

PSA 9

1998 Topps #360 Peyton Manning RC Rookie PSA 9 GEM MINT HOF Colts Broncos

$100

View on eBay

PSA 8

2025 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Ultra Violet PSA 8 #UV-8 Colts

$400

View on eBay

PSA 9

2007 Topps Chrome - Peyton Manning #TC96 XFractor PSA 9 HOF Indianapolis Colts

$150

View on eBay

PSA 9

PEYTON MANNING 2000 UPPER DECK PROS PROSPECTS SIGNATURE PIECE JERSEY AUTO PSA 9

$750

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

$2015 Topps Finest Peyton Manning #66 Black Refractor *PSA 10*. Pop 13$

PSA 10

2015 Topps Finest Peyton Manning #66 Black Refractor PSA 10. Pop 13

$210

View on eBay

PSA 9

2005 Topps Finest Peyton Manning #120 BLUE REFRACTOR/299 PSA 9

$250

View on eBay

PSA 9

1998 Collector's Edge Peyton Manning Promo Holding Jersey RC PSA 9 Mint

$50

View on eBay

PSA 10

PEYTON MANNING 1998 Topps Season Opener. PSA Graded Gem Mt 10

$465

View on eBay

1998 Topps Finest - Rookie Peyton Manning #121 (RC)

$95

View on eBay

PSA 10

Peyton Manning Card VTG 1999 Graded PSA 10 Gem MT Colts Topps Stadium Club Slab

$148

View on eBay

2010 EXQUISITE GAME USED JERSEY AUTO BOOKLET PEYTON ELI MANNING & DREW BREES /10

$1,800

View on eBay

BGS 9.5

2016 Panini Immaculate Collection Peyton Manning Moments Auto /5 BGS 9.5 (G)

$2,500

View on eBay

PSA 10

1998 Stadium Club Peyton Manning Rookie RC #195 PSA 10 - Indianapolis Colts

$140

View on eBay

PSA 8

PSA 8 - PEYTON WATSON #/9 Auto - 2022 Leaf Exotic RC Autograph - ZEBRA PRISMATIC

$63

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

PSA 10

2013 Panini Prizm Peyton Manning #77 PSA 10

$45

View on eBay

PEYTON MANNING 2001 UPPER DECK GAME WORN USED JERSEY ON CARD AUTO AUTOGRAPH PMAJ

$400

View on eBay

$Peyton Manning 2026 Leaf Football Pay Dirt Comichrome Auto 1/1 Superfractor Colt$

Peyton Manning 2026 Leaf Football Pay Dirt Comichrome Auto 1/1 Superfractor Colt

$250

View on eBay

PSA 10

2009 SP Authentic Ben Roethlisberger Eli Manning Peyton Manning PSA 10 AUTO 1/25

$2,500

View on eBay

Peyton Manning 2017 Plates And Patches /3 Game Used Auto

$550

View on eBay

PSA 9

2021 Flawless Peyton Manning Auto Game Worn Jersey Patch /6 PSA 9

$1,999

View on eBay

$1999 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning Stock in the Game Refractor #S12 Colts PSA 10$

PSA 10

1999 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning Stock in the Game Refractor #S12 Colts PSA 10

$89

View on eBay

PSA 9

1998 peyton Manning Flair showcaee row 1 psa 9

$225

View on eBay

PSA 9

2000 Collectors Edge Peyton Manning #150 Uncirculated Graded PSA 9 Colts HOF

$18

View on eBay

PSA 10

2010 Topps Chrome X-Fractor #C50 PEYTON MANNING – PSA 10 GEM MINT!

$140

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

PSA 8

1998 Bowman Peyton Manning Gold Rookie PSA 8!! COLTS BRONCOS

$35

View on eBay

$2006 Bowman Chrome Blue Refractor Peyton Manning /150 PSA 9 (pop:4, higher:1)$

PSA 9

2006 Bowman Chrome Blue Refractor Peyton Manning /150 PSA 9 (pop:4, higher:1)

$160

View on eBay

PSA 10

2013 PANINI SELECT PEYTON MANNING HOT STARS #12 BRONCOS HOF PSA 10 GEM MINT

$35

View on eBay

PSA 10

2000 Collector's Edge Masters PEYTON MANNING #/2000 PSA 10

$75

View on eBay

PSA 10

2008 Upper Deck Heroes Peyton Manning #79 Colts HOF PSA 10

$30

View on eBay

PSA 10

1999 Stadium Club 3x3 Peyton Manning Illuminator #T4A PSA 10 POP 11 SSP 1:4320

$299

View on eBay

PSA 9

Peyton Manning 1999 Upper Deck MVP #D10 Dynamics Indianapolis Colts PSA 9

$24

View on eBay

2007 UltimateCollection Peyton Manning #UM-PE Silver /125 PSA 7

$60

View on eBay

PSA 8

Peyton Manning (RC) Grade PSA 8 - 1998 Bowman Chrome Rookie #1

$58

View on eBay

$2009 Bowman Chrome #12 Peyton Manning Xfractor /250 PSA 8$

PSA 8

2009 Bowman Chrome #12 Peyton Manning Xfractor /250 PSA 8

$98

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

PSA 9

2001 Topps Heritage #25 Peyton Manning PSA 9 MINT; Indianapolis Colts; HOF NFL

$25

View on eBay

PSA 9

2017 Panini Pantheon Metal #55 Peyton Manning /30 PSA 9 Colts

$103

View on eBay

1998 TOPPS CHROME #165 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 6

$69

View on eBay

PSA 9

Peyton Manning 2000 Collector's Edge Uncirculated PSA 9 #150 Indianapolis Colts

$17

View on eBay

1998 Upper Deck - NFL Star Rookie Peyton Manning #1 (RC) PSA 7

$26

View on eBay

2023 Immaculate Peyton Manning Immaculate Records Auto /25 See Description

$270

View on eBay

2019 Panini Flawless Peyton Manning Legends Platinum Diamond #1/1 One of One

$1000

View on eBay

$1999 Finest Peyton Manning Rookie Refractor PSA10 GEM #142$

1999 Finest Peyton Manning Rookie Refractor PSA10 GEM #142

$190

View on eBay

2006 TOPPS FOOTBALL #51 PEYTON MANNING BLACK BORDER COLTS RARE SP #28/51 PSA 7!

$299

View on eBay

PSA 10

2024 TOPPS CHROME PEYTON MANNING #H3 HELIX PSA 10

$175

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

PSA 9

1999 Flair Showcase #70 PEYTON MANNING PSA 9 Mint Colts

$43

View on eBay

2000 EX - E-Xceptional Peyton Manning #2 XC Green PSA Colts HOF

$40

View on eBay

PSA 8

2024 Topps Chrome Legends of the Gridiron Peyton Manning LOG-2 PSA 8

$10

View on eBay

PSA 10

1998 Collector's Edge Peyton Manning Promo Graded ROOKIE Card PSA 10 Collectors

$86

View on eBay

PSA 10

Peyton Manning PSA 10 Press Proof Premium 2021 Panini Donruss GEM MINT

$18

View on eBay

PSA 9

2005 Topps Chrome - Peyton Manning #136 PSA 9

$15

View on eBay

PSA 10

1998 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning RC #165 PSA 10 💎

$1,450

View on eBay

PSA 9

2000 Collector's Edge Graded - Peyton Manning #150 PSA 9

$16

View on eBay

PSA 10

1998 Topps Gold Label - Peyton Manning #20 Class 1 (RC) PSA 10 Gem MINT Card

$320

View on eBay

$1999 Bowman's Best Peyton Manning Refractor #70 PSA 9 /400$

PSA 9

1999 Bowman's Best Peyton Manning Refractor #70 PSA 9 /400

$175

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

PSA 10

1998 BOWMAN #1 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 10

$260

View on eBay

PSA 9

1998 Topps Peyton Manning Rookie - PSA 9 - #360

$100

View on eBay

PSA 9

1998 Upper Deck Black Diamond Rookies Single - PEYTON MANNING - PSA 9 Mint (RC)

$79

View on eBay

BGS 9.5

Upper Deck 2006 SPx Super Scripts Peyton Manning Colts Auto SS-PM /50 BGS 9.5

$484

View on eBay

PSA 9

2017 Panini Pantheon Metal #55 Peyton Manning /50 PSA 9 Colts

$103

View on eBay

PSA 9

1998 Bowman's Best Peyton Manning #112 (RC) - PSA 9 - Mint - Rookie Card

$49

View on eBay

PSA 10

2011 TOPPS #368 INDIANAPOLIS COLTS PEYTON MANNING PSA 10

$25

View on eBay

Peyton Manning Signed 5x7 Photo Indianapolis Colts Autographed PSA/DNA COA

$150

View on eBay

PSA 10

2003 SP Authentic - Sign of the Times Peyton Manning Auto #PM /900 PSA 10/10

$542

View on eBay

PSA 10

2016 Panini Prestige Peyton Manning Xtra Points Gold /50 #57 PSA GEM MT 10

$85

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

PSA 10

Peyton Manning 1998 Collector's Edge Odyssey Holding Jersey Promo RC PSA 10 HOF!

$100

View on eBay

PSA 8

1998 Upper Deck Encore #1 Peyton Manning PSA 8 Rookie RC Colts Broncos HOF

$70

View on eBay

PSA 9

PSA 9 1998 98 Bowman Chrome REFRACTOR Preview PEYTON MANNING RC Rookie #BCP1 REF

$385

View on eBay

PSA 10

2023 Panini Donruss Football Downtown #D9 Peyton Manning PSA 10 GEM SSP

$799

View on eBay

PSA 9

2011 SCORE #128 PEYTON MANNING COLTS HOF PSA 9

$15

View on eBay

$Peyton Manning 2006 Topps Chrome Black Refractor 108/199 PSA Mint 9$

Peyton Manning 2006 Topps Chrome Black Refractor 108/199 PSA Mint 9

$300

View on eBay

$2003 Topps Draft Picks/Pros Chrome #10 Peyton Manning Gold Refractor PSA 8$

PSA 8

2003 Topps Draft Picks/Pros Chrome #10 Peyton Manning Gold Refractor PSA 8

$45

View on eBay

PSA 9

1999 TOPPS CHROME REFRACTOR #120 PEYTON MANNING PSA 9

$225

View on eBay

PSA 10

1999 Topps Finest - Peyton Manning #1 PSA 10 Colts 2nd Year

$55

View on eBay

$Peyton Manning All-Etch Refractor - 1999 Topps Chrome #AE19 - PSA 10 (POP: 34)$

PSA 10

Peyton Manning All-Etch Refractor - 1999 Topps Chrome #AE19 - PSA 10 (POP: 34)

$500

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

PSA 10

PEYTON MANNING 2024 SELECT SUITE LEVEL COSMIC PRIZM REFRACTOR PSA 10 POP 3

$300

View on eBay

PSA 9

1998 Topps Finest Peyton Manning #121 Rookie Card RC Indianapolis Colts PSA 9

$60

View on eBay

PSA 9

1998 Topps Stars #67 Gold /1999 Peyton Manning RC PSA 9 Mint Rare Topps Rookie

$250

View on eBay

PSA 9

Collector's Edge 2000 Graded Peyton Manning #150 Uncirculated PSA 9 /5000 Colts

$16

View on eBay

PSA 9

1998 TOPPS CHROME #165 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 9

$199

View on eBay

PSA 10

1999 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning #70 PSA 10 GEM MINT

$90

View on eBay

Peyton Manning PSA Magazine September 2025 CGC 9.4 SP HOF Colts Broncos Legend

$150

View on eBay

PSA 9

2021 Contenders To Canton On Card Auto Peyton Manning /20 PSA 9

$300

View on eBay

PSA 10

2023 Select Peyton Manning Dragon Scale Prizm /70 PSA 10 Gem MINT

$160

View on eBay

PEYTON MANNING 2008 UPPER DECK MASTERPIECES AUTO PSA SIGNED AUTOGRAPH COLTS

$175

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

Live Graded Cards

1998 Pinnacle Peyton Manning Mint Collection #99 PSA 8

Peyton Manning - you choose! Inserts, Parallels, Game-Used, RCs! Colts NrMt

1998 Peyton Manning Bowman's Best #112 RC Rookie Card Indianapolis Colts PSA 9

1999 Fleer #7 Peyton Manning Under Pressure Die-Cut PSA 8

2001 UD Graded - Game Used Jerseys Peyton Manning #PM PSA 9 Colts HOF

2014 Certified Pro Bowl Bound Peyton Manning #PB2 GREEN /5 🏦 PSA 10 🏦 HOF

1998 Upper Deck UD Choice #256 Peyton Manning Rookie RC PSA 9

Peyton Manning 1998 Topps #360 RC Rookie Colts PSA 9 MINT HOF Centered Resub

1998 Bowman Chrome - Peyton Manning #1 (RC) PSA 9 OLD LABEL

1998 Skybox E-X 2001 Peyton Manning #54 PSA 7 Rookie RC HOF 0k2i

Peyton Manning 1999 Playoff Contenders Season Ticket 💎 PSA 10 💎 POP 9 💎 #104

1998 Fleer Ultra Gold Medallion Peyton Manning Rookie #201G PSA 9

1998 SKYBOX E-X2001 #54 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 9

2006 Topps #288 Peyton Manning PSA 10 🏈 💥

1998 Bowman Interstate Peyton Manning #1 Rookie RC HOF PSA 10

Topps 2007 Chrome Peyton Manning #TC5 Red Refractor /250 PSA 10 Colts

1998 Topps #360 Peyton Manning RC Rookie PSA 9 GEM MINT HOF Colts Broncos

2025 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Ultra Violet PSA 8 #UV-8 Colts

2007 Topps Chrome - Peyton Manning #TC96 XFractor PSA 9 HOF Indianapolis Colts

PEYTON MANNING 2000 UPPER DECK PROS PROSPECTS SIGNATURE PIECE JERSEY AUTO PSA 9

2015 Topps Finest Peyton Manning #66 Black Refractor *PSA 10*. Pop 13

2005 Topps Finest Peyton Manning #120 BLUE REFRACTOR/299 PSA 9

1998 Collector's Edge Peyton Manning Promo Holding Jersey RC PSA 9 Mint

PEYTON MANNING 1998 Topps Season Opener. PSA Graded Gem Mt 10

1998 Topps Finest - Rookie Peyton Manning #121 (RC)

Peyton Manning Card VTG 1999 Graded PSA 10 Gem MT Colts Topps Stadium Club Slab

2010 EXQUISITE GAME USED JERSEY AUTO BOOKLET PEYTON ELI MANNING & DREW BREES /10

2016 Panini Immaculate Collection Peyton Manning Moments Auto /5 BGS 9.5 (G)

1998 Stadium Club Peyton Manning Rookie RC #195 PSA 10 - Indianapolis Colts

PSA 8 - PEYTON WATSON #/9 Auto - 2022 Leaf Exotic RC Autograph - ZEBRA PRISMATIC

2013 Panini Prizm Peyton Manning #77 PSA 10

PEYTON MANNING 2001 UPPER DECK GAME WORN USED JERSEY ON CARD AUTO AUTOGRAPH PMAJ

Peyton Manning 2026 Leaf Football Pay Dirt Comichrome Auto 1/1 Superfractor Colt

2009 SP Authentic Ben Roethlisberger Eli Manning Peyton Manning PSA 10 AUTO 1/25

Peyton Manning 2017 Plates And Patches /3 Game Used Auto

2021 Flawless Peyton Manning Auto Game Worn Jersey Patch /6 PSA 9

1999 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning Stock in the Game Refractor #S12 Colts PSA 10

1998 peyton Manning Flair showcaee row 1 psa 9

2000 Collectors Edge Peyton Manning #150 Uncirculated Graded PSA 9 Colts HOF

2010 Topps Chrome X-Fractor #C50 PEYTON MANNING – PSA 10 GEM MINT!

1998 Bowman Peyton Manning Gold Rookie PSA 8!! COLTS BRONCOS

2006 Bowman Chrome Blue Refractor Peyton Manning /150 PSA 9 (pop:4, higher:1)

2013 PANINI SELECT PEYTON MANNING HOT STARS #12 BRONCOS HOF PSA 10 GEM MINT

2000 Collector's Edge Masters PEYTON MANNING #/2000 PSA 10

2008 Upper Deck Heroes Peyton Manning #79 Colts HOF PSA 10

1999 Stadium Club 3x3 Peyton Manning Illuminator #T4A PSA 10 POP 11 SSP 1:4320

Peyton Manning 1999 Upper Deck MVP #D10 Dynamics Indianapolis Colts PSA 9

2007 UltimateCollection Peyton Manning #UM-PE Silver /125 PSA 7

Peyton Manning (RC) Grade PSA 8 - 1998 Bowman Chrome Rookie #1

2009 Bowman Chrome #12 Peyton Manning Xfractor /250 PSA 8

2001 Topps Heritage #25 Peyton Manning PSA 9 MINT; Indianapolis Colts; HOF NFL

2017 Panini Pantheon Metal #55 Peyton Manning /30 PSA 9 Colts

1998 TOPPS CHROME #165 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 6

Peyton Manning 2000 Collector's Edge Uncirculated PSA 9 #150 Indianapolis Colts

1998 Upper Deck - NFL Star Rookie Peyton Manning #1 (RC) PSA 7

2023 Immaculate Peyton Manning Immaculate Records Auto /25 See Description

2019 Panini Flawless Peyton Manning Legends Platinum Diamond #1/1 One of One

1999 Finest Peyton Manning Rookie Refractor PSA10 GEM #142

2006 TOPPS FOOTBALL #51 PEYTON MANNING BLACK BORDER COLTS RARE SP #28/51 PSA 7!

2024 TOPPS CHROME PEYTON MANNING #H3 HELIX PSA 10

1999 Flair Showcase #70 PEYTON MANNING PSA 9 Mint Colts

2000 EX - E-Xceptional Peyton Manning #2 XC Green PSA Colts HOF

2024 Topps Chrome Legends of the Gridiron Peyton Manning LOG-2 PSA 8

1998 Collector's Edge Peyton Manning Promo Graded ROOKIE Card PSA 10 Collectors

Peyton Manning PSA 10 Press Proof Premium 2021 Panini Donruss GEM MINT

2005 Topps Chrome - Peyton Manning #136 PSA 9

1998 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning RC #165 PSA 10 💎

2000 Collector's Edge Graded - Peyton Manning #150 PSA 9

1998 Topps Gold Label - Peyton Manning #20 Class 1 (RC) PSA 10 Gem MINT Card

1999 Bowman's Best Peyton Manning Refractor #70 PSA 9 /400

1998 BOWMAN #1 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 10

1998 Topps Peyton Manning Rookie - PSA 9 - #360

1998 Upper Deck Black Diamond Rookies Single - PEYTON MANNING - PSA 9 Mint (RC)

Upper Deck 2006 SPx Super Scripts Peyton Manning Colts Auto SS-PM /50 BGS 9.5

2017 Panini Pantheon Metal #55 Peyton Manning /50 PSA 9 Colts

1998 Bowman's Best Peyton Manning #112 (RC) - PSA 9 - Mint - Rookie Card

2011 TOPPS #368 INDIANAPOLIS COLTS PEYTON MANNING PSA 10

Peyton Manning Signed 5x7 Photo Indianapolis Colts Autographed PSA/DNA COA

2003 SP Authentic - Sign of the Times Peyton Manning Auto #PM /900 PSA 10/10

2015 Topps Finest Peyton Manning #66 Black Refractor PSA 10. Pop 13

PEYTON MANNING 2024 SELECT SUITE LEVEL COSMIC PRIZM REFRACTOR PSA 10 POP 3