Live Auction Floor — 710 Graded Cards

PSA 9

1998 Collectors Edge Supreme Season Review Peyton Manning #74B Gold Ingot PSA 10

$305

View on eBay

PSA 10

PEYTON MANNING 2021 PANINI PHOENIX GREEN CARD #17/25 PSA GEM MT 10!

$65

View on eBay

Peyton Manning PSA Gem Mint 10 - 2013 Panini Select Hot stars #12

$70

View on eBay

PSA 10

2016 Donruss Optic Tribute Red Peyton Manning /99 #8 PSA 10 GEM MINT Pop 1

$100

View on eBay

1998 Upper Deck - NFL Star Rookie Peyton Manning #1 (RC) PSA 7

$46

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

PSA 10

Peyton manning 1999 Bowman's Best #95 PSA 10 Best Performers

$60

View on eBay

PSA 8

1999 Fleer Tradition PEYTON MANNING Under Pressure Die-Cut PSA 8 NM-MT Colts

$125

View on eBay

PSA 10

1998 Topps Action Flats Peyton Manning #K5 PSA 10

$575

View on eBay

$1998 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning Refractor RC #1 PSA 9 MINT HOF Colts Football$

PSA 9

1998 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning Refractor RC #1 PSA 9 MINT HOF Colts Football

$1,499

View on eBay

PSA 10

PSA 10 Gem Mint Rc Peyton Manning Rookie 1998 Skybox E-X 2001 Stardate 2001 #15

$750

View on eBay

PSA 9

PEYTON MANNING 2007 TOPPS CHROME COLTS LEGEND REFRACTOR #TC5 PSA 9 MINT

$110

View on eBay

Peyton Manning signed autographed PSA DNA slabbed Topps Denver Broncos QB

$199

View on eBay

PSA 10

1998 Collector's Edge Peyton Manning RC PSA 10 Gem Top Rookie Variation #135

$130

View on eBay

$2023 Topps Composite Chrome Peyton Manning PSA 10 All Etch Gold Refractor /50 #d$

PSA 10

2023 Topps Composite Chrome Peyton Manning PSA 10 All Etch Gold Refractor /50 #d

$127

View on eBay

PSA 10

RARE CASE HIT 2024 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Topps Helix H-3 PSA 10 GEM MINT

$175

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

PSA 8

1998 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning #165 PSA 8 Rookie RC HOF COLTS!!

$170

View on eBay

PSA 10

1998 Bowman Peyton Manning Rookie RC #1 Colts PSA 10

$320

View on eBay

PSA 9

1998 TOPPS CHROME #165 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 9

$400

View on eBay

$2006 Topps Chrome - Peyton Manning #8 Refractor PSA 9$

PSA 9

2006 Topps Chrome - Peyton Manning #8 Refractor PSA 9

$120

View on eBay

PSA 8

1998 Upper Deck Super Powers Peyton Manning Rookie RC Colts #S16 PSA 8

$12

View on eBay

2014 Topps Museum Collection Peyton Manning Silver Framed Auto #/25 PSA AUTO 10

$450

View on eBay

PSA 9

1998 Leaf Rookies & Stars Peyton Manning #233 Rookie PSA 9 Mint Colts HOF (RC)

$67

View on eBay

PSA 8

1999 Topps Finest - Peyton Manning #1 With Coating PSA 8

$25

View on eBay

PSA 9

Peyton Manning PSA 9 - 2000 EX - E-Xceptional #2 XC Red - Indianapolis Colts

$61

View on eBay

PSA 10

Peyton Manning 1998 Bowman #1 RC Rookie Card Colts PSA 10 GEM MINT

$350

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

Peyton Manning / Autographed Denver Broncos M&N Pro-Style Football Jersey / PSA

$480

View on eBay

Peyton Manning signed autographed PSA DNA slabbed Donruss Indianapolis Colts QB

$199

View on eBay

PSA 9

2025 Peyton Manning Panini Silhouette White Night Case Hit SSP PSA 9

$450

View on eBay

1998 Collector’s Edge Peyton Manning Rc PSA/DNA - SUPER VALUE !!!!

$250

View on eBay

PEYTON MANNING~1998 BOWMAN CHROME PSA-9 MINT HOT GRADED NFL ROOKIE RC CARD #1

$130

View on eBay

PSA 10

1998 BOWMAN'S BEST #112 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 10

$240

View on eBay

1998 Finest Stadium Stars #SS9 Peyton Manning RC-Rookie Colts graded PSA 7 NM

$150

View on eBay

PSA 10

1998 Fleer Brilliants - Blue #120B Peyton Manning (RC) PSA 10

$750

View on eBay

2025 Panini Prizm Black - Peyton Manning #71 Gold Prizm /10

$800

View on eBay

PSA 9

1998 FLAIR SHOWCASE ROW 3 #3 PEYTON MANNING RC COLTS HOF PSA 9

$50

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

PSA 9

1998 Topps Season Opener Peyton Manning RC #1 PSA 9 MINT HOF

$80

View on eBay

$2014 Bowman Chrome Blue Refractor /199 #24 Peyton Manning PSA 9$

PSA 9

2014 Bowman Chrome Blue Refractor /199 #24 Peyton Manning PSA 9

$96

View on eBay

PSA 10

Peyton Manning PSA 10 - 2013 Prizm #77 BLUE PRIZM - HOF - Denver Broncos

$299

View on eBay

PSA 8

1998 Upper Deck Encore Peyton Manning Rookie Card #1 PSA 8 Star Rookie HOF

$64

View on eBay

PSA 9

2025 PANINI DONRUSS ALL-TIME GRIDIRON KINGS #ATGK-PMG PEYTON MANNING PSA 9

$31

View on eBay

PSA 9

2022 Prizm Peyton Manning PSA 9 Sensational Signatures 4/5 ***See Pics And Des.

$400

View on eBay

PSA 9

Peyton Manning Nico Iamaleava 2024 Wild Card Green Rainbow Foil 1/1 PSA 9 Mint

$89

View on eBay

2017 Immaculate - Game Worn! Dual Jerseys Peyton Manning Andrew Luck 21/25!

$89

View on eBay

PSA 9

2005 Upper Deck Rookie Debut Peyton Manning Game Worn Patch Pop 5 PSA 9

$50

View on eBay

PSA 10

1998 Topps Peyton Manning 20 Gold Label Class 2 Rookie PSA 10 Gem Mint Pop 59

$390

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

PSA 10

1998 Topps Finest - Rookie Peyton Manning PSA 10 GEM MT

$300

View on eBay

PSA 10

2002 LEAF CERTIFIED SKILLS FOOTBALL CARD #CS-4 HOF PEYTON MANNING PSA 10 POP 1

$67

View on eBay

PSA 10

1999 Topps Finest Peyton Manning Prominent Figures /5084 #PF6 PSA 10 Colts

$250

View on eBay

PSA 9

1998 TOPPS CHROME #165 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC CARD INDIANAPOLIS COLTS PSA 9

$650

View on eBay

PSA 9

1998 Topps Peyton Manning Football NFL Indianapolis Colts RC Card #360 PSA 9

$185

View on eBay

1998 Flair Showcase Row 1 Peyton Manning #3 PSA 7

$169

View on eBay

PSA 8

Peyton Manning Rookie PSA 8 Graded 1998 Metal Universe #189

$37

View on eBay

PSA 9

1999 Flair Showcase #70 PEYTON MANNING PSA 9 Mint Colts 🔥

$47

View on eBay

PEYTON MANNING~1998 ROOKIE PLAYOFF CONTENDERS LEATHER PSA-10 GEM-MT RC CARD #37

$300

View on eBay

Peyton Manning Signed 5x7 Photo Indianapolis Colts Autographed PSA/DNA COA

$175

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

PSA 9

1998 Flair Showcase #3 Peyton Manning Row 3 RC PSA 9 Mint Colts

$55

View on eBay

$2003 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Colts #45 Black Refractor 599/599 PSA 9 bookend$

PSA 9

2003 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Colts #45 Black Refractor 599/599 PSA 9 bookend

$600

View on eBay

PSA 8

2020 Panini Absolute Peyton Manning Iconic Ink 3/10 | PSA 8/Auto 10 #II-PM

$350

View on eBay

PSA 9

1999 E-X Century Peyton Manning E-Xtraordinary SP #15 of 15 XT PSA 9 MINT Colts

$80

View on eBay

$2008 Leaf R&S Rookies Stars #/25 Peyton Manning PSA 10 Black Longevity Refractor$

PSA 10

2008 Leaf R&S Rookies Stars #/25 Peyton Manning PSA 10 Black Longevity Refractor

$350

View on eBay

1998 SPx Finite Rookies Peyton Manning #181 Ser#0674/1998 PSA (RC)

$130

View on eBay

PSA 10

1998 Bowman #1 Peyton Manning RC PSA 10 Gem Mint Colts

$400

View on eBay

$Peyton Manning Refractor - 2009 Topps Finest #60 - PSA 10 (POP: 20)$

PSA 10

Peyton Manning Refractor - 2009 Topps Finest #60 - PSA 10 (POP: 20)

$300

View on eBay

PSA 9

1999 Donruss Preferred PEYTON MANNING X-Ponential Power INSERT /2500 PSA 9 HOF

$150

View on eBay

$2002 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Black Refractor /599 PSA 9 Mint$

PSA 9

2002 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Black Refractor /599 PSA 9 Mint

$800

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

PSA 10

Peyton Manning - 1998 Topps Finest RC #121 - Colts Rookie HOF GEM MINT - PSA 10

$225

View on eBay

PSA 10

1998 Collector’s Edge 1st Place Peyton Manning PSA 10 Gem Mint

$119

View on eBay

PSA 10

2014 SP AUTHENTIC #134 PEYTON MANNING BRONCOS HOF PSA 10

$40

View on eBay

PSA 9

1998 Topps Peyton Manning #360 (RC) - PSA 9 MINT 🔥🔥🔥 - Indianapolis Colts

$229

View on eBay

PSA 9

2022 Flawless Peyton Manning Player Worn Patch-Auto PSA 8/PSA 9!!!🔥

$975

View on eBay

PSA 10

2003 Topps Peyton Manning #HM8 Hobby Masters PSA 10 GEM MINT HOF Pop 6

$350

View on eBay

PSA 8

2011 Topps Finest X-Fractor 277/399 Peyton Manning #80 PSA 8 HOF 10p1

$54

View on eBay

$2001 Topps Chrome Refractor Peyton Manning #98 Graded PSA 9 /999 Low Pop!$

PSA 9

2001 Topps Chrome Refractor Peyton Manning #98 Graded PSA 9 /999 Low Pop!

$400

View on eBay

PSA 10

vintage PSA 10 - SUPER BOWL XLI COLTS vs BEARS FULL TICKET - PEYTON MANNING MVP

$459

View on eBay

PEYTON MANNING #16 SIGNED TENNESSEE VOLUNTEERS MITCHELL & NESS JERSEY PSA/DNA

$1000

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

PSA 10

2023 Panini Donruss Optic Downtown! #D9 Peyton Manning PSA 10

$1,100

View on eBay

PSA 10

Peyton Manning Card VTG 1999 Graded PSA 10 Gem MT Colts Topps Stadium Club Slab

$147

View on eBay

2024 Leaf Gold Prizm 1/1 GU Patch Tom Brady Peyton Manning Joe Montana 8.5 BGS

$1,499

View on eBay

2026 Wild Card National - Peyton Manning - Graffiti Matte Metal Auto True 1/1

$400

View on eBay

PSA 10

2014 Topps Finest Peyton Manning #50 PSA 10 Gem Mint

$50

View on eBay

PSA 9

2022 Panini Flawless Collegiate Peyton Manning Patch Auto /25 PSA 9 RARE

$825

View on eBay

PSA 10

2022 Select Peyton Watson Rookie Signature Gold Auto /10 RC #RSPYW PSA 10 -POP 1

$950

View on eBay

$1999 Finest Refractor Peyton Manning #1 PSA 9$

PSA 9

1999 Finest Refractor Peyton Manning #1 PSA 9

$400

View on eBay

PSA 9

2007 UD Trilogy Peyton Manning Signature Present /33 PSA 9/10 #PRSPM #SSP POP 3

$550

View on eBay

$Topps 1999 Bowman's Best Peyton Manning #70 Refractor /400 Colts PSA 9 POP 32$

PSA 9

Topps 1999 Bowman's Best Peyton Manning #70 Refractor /400 Colts PSA 9 POP 32

$740

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

$1998 Peyton Manning Topps Finest Undergrads Refractor W/ Coating PSA 7 U20 RC$

1998 Peyton Manning Topps Finest Undergrads Refractor W/ Coating PSA 7 U20 RC

$350

View on eBay

$2008 Topps Letterman - Peyton Manning #3 Refractor 61/99 PSA 8$

PSA 8

2008 Topps Letterman - Peyton Manning #3 Refractor 61/99 PSA 8

$60

View on eBay

PSA 10

2012 Topps #350 PEYTON MANNING PSA 10 Gem Mint

$54

View on eBay

PSA 9

1998 Topps #360 Peyton Manning PSA 9 ROOKIE RC COLTS

$300

View on eBay

2002 Upper Deck American Authentics Peyton Manning Auto Colts PSA 7 Auto

$199

View on eBay

$1998 Bowman Chrome - Preview Peyton Manning #BCP1 Refractor (RC) PSA 8$

PSA 8

1998 Bowman Chrome - Preview Peyton Manning #BCP1 Refractor (RC) PSA 8

$850

View on eBay

PSA 10

PEYTON MANNING 2011 TOPPS LEGENDS FOOTBALL GOLD COLTS GEM /99 PSA 10 Q5775

$90

View on eBay

PSA 8

2003 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning #38 COLTS SP REFRACTOR /500 PSA 8

$285

View on eBay

PSA 9

Topps 1998 Chrome Draft Picks Peyton Manning #165 RC Colts PSA 9

$675

View on eBay

1999 Skybox Molten Metal — PLAYER’S PARTY — Peyton Manning — PSA 6 — pop 1 READ

$150

View on eBay

eBay Partner Network affiliate: HoodCar may earn a commission on eBay purchases. HoodCar is not eBay and is not endorsed by eBay Inc.

Live Graded Cards

1999 Donruss Elite - Passing The Torch Peyton Manning #3 /1500 PSA 9 Mint

1998 Bowman Peyton Manning RC #1 PSA 10 Gem Mint

2013 Panini Score Peyton Manning #276 Denver Broncos PSA 10

PEYTON MANNING 16X20 AUTOGRAPHED PHOTO W/ INSCRIPTION

1998 Topps Finest Peyton Manning Rookie #121 PSA 10 Gem Mint w/ Coating Colts

1998 Collectors Edge Supreme Season Review Peyton Manning #74B Gold Ingot PSA 10

PEYTON MANNING 2021 PANINI PHOENIX GREEN CARD #17/25 PSA GEM MT 10!

Peyton Manning PSA Gem Mint 10 - 2013 Panini Select Hot stars #12

2016 Donruss Optic Tribute Red Peyton Manning /99 #8 PSA 10 GEM MINT Pop 1

1998 Upper Deck - NFL Star Rookie Peyton Manning #1 (RC) PSA 7

Peyton manning 1999 Bowman's Best #95 PSA 10 Best Performers

1999 Fleer Tradition PEYTON MANNING Under Pressure Die-Cut PSA 8 NM-MT Colts

1998 Topps Action Flats Peyton Manning #K5 PSA 10

1998 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning Refractor RC #1 PSA 9 MINT HOF Colts Football

PSA 10 Gem Mint Rc Peyton Manning Rookie 1998 Skybox E-X 2001 Stardate 2001 #15

PEYTON MANNING 2007 TOPPS CHROME COLTS LEGEND *REFRACTOR* #TC5 PSA 9 MINT

Peyton Manning signed autographed PSA DNA slabbed Topps Denver Broncos QB

1998 Collector's Edge Peyton Manning RC PSA 10 Gem Top Rookie Variation #135

2023 Topps Composite Chrome Peyton Manning PSA 10 All Etch Gold Refractor /50 #d

RARE CASE HIT 2024 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Topps Helix H-3 PSA 10 GEM MINT

1998 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning #165 PSA 8 Rookie RC HOF COLTS!!

1998 Bowman Peyton Manning Rookie RC #1 Colts PSA 10

1998 TOPPS CHROME #165 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 9

2006 Topps Chrome - Peyton Manning #8 Refractor PSA 9

1998 Upper Deck Super Powers Peyton Manning Rookie RC Colts #S16 PSA 8

2014 Topps Museum Collection Peyton Manning Silver Framed Auto #/25 PSA AUTO 10

1998 Leaf Rookies & Stars Peyton Manning #233 Rookie PSA 9 Mint Colts HOF (RC)

1999 Topps Finest - Peyton Manning #1 With Coating PSA 8

Peyton Manning PSA 9 - 2000 EX - E-Xceptional #2 XC Red - Indianapolis Colts

Peyton Manning 1998 Bowman #1 RC Rookie Card Colts PSA 10 GEM MINT

Peyton Manning / Autographed Denver Broncos M&N Pro-Style Football Jersey / PSA

Peyton Manning signed autographed PSA DNA slabbed Donruss Indianapolis Colts QB

2025 Peyton Manning Panini Silhouette White Night Case Hit SSP PSA 9

1998 Collector’s Edge Peyton Manning Rc PSA/DNA - SUPER VALUE !!!!

PEYTON MANNING~1998 BOWMAN CHROME PSA-9 MINT HOT GRADED NFL ROOKIE RC CARD #1

1998 BOWMAN'S BEST #112 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 10

1998 Finest Stadium Stars #SS9 Peyton Manning RC-Rookie Colts graded PSA 7 NM

1998 Fleer Brilliants - Blue #120B Peyton Manning (RC) PSA 10

2025 Panini Prizm Black - Peyton Manning #71 Gold Prizm /10

1998 FLAIR SHOWCASE ROW 3 #3 PEYTON MANNING RC COLTS HOF PSA 9

1998 Topps Season Opener Peyton Manning RC #1 PSA 9 MINT HOF

2014 Bowman Chrome Blue Refractor /199 #24 Peyton Manning PSA 9

Peyton Manning PSA 10 - 2013 Prizm #77 BLUE PRIZM - HOF - Denver Broncos

1998 Upper Deck Encore Peyton Manning Rookie Card #1 PSA 8 Star Rookie HOF

2025 PANINI DONRUSS ALL-TIME GRIDIRON KINGS #ATGK-PMG PEYTON MANNING PSA 9

2022 Prizm Peyton Manning PSA 9 Sensational Signatures 4/5 ***See Pics And Des.

Peyton Manning Nico Iamaleava 2024 Wild Card Green Rainbow Foil 1/1 PSA 9 Mint

2017 Immaculate - Game Worn! Dual Jerseys Peyton Manning Andrew Luck 21/25!

2005 Upper Deck Rookie Debut Peyton Manning Game Worn Patch Pop 5 PSA 9

1998 Topps Peyton Manning 20 Gold Label Class 2 Rookie PSA 10 Gem Mint Pop 59

1998 Topps Finest - Rookie Peyton Manning PSA 10 GEM MT

2002 LEAF CERTIFIED SKILLS FOOTBALL CARD #CS-4 HOF PEYTON MANNING PSA 10 POP 1

1999 Topps Finest Peyton Manning Prominent Figures /5084 #PF6 PSA 10 Colts

1998 TOPPS CHROME #165 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC CARD INDIANAPOLIS COLTS PSA 9

1998 Topps Peyton Manning Football NFL Indianapolis Colts RC Card #360 PSA 9

1998 Flair Showcase Row 1 Peyton Manning #3 PSA 7

Peyton Manning Rookie PSA 8 Graded 1998 Metal Universe #189

1999 Flair Showcase #70 PEYTON MANNING PSA 9 Mint Colts 🔥

PEYTON MANNING~1998 ROOKIE PLAYOFF CONTENDERS LEATHER PSA-10 GEM-MT RC CARD #37

Peyton Manning Signed 5x7 Photo Indianapolis Colts Autographed PSA/DNA COA

1998 Flair Showcase #3 Peyton Manning Row 3 RC PSA 9 Mint Colts

2003 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Colts #45 Black Refractor 599/599 PSA 9 bookend

2020 Panini Absolute Peyton Manning Iconic Ink 3/10 | PSA 8/Auto 10 #II-PM

1999 E-X Century Peyton Manning E-Xtraordinary SP #15 of 15 XT PSA 9 MINT Colts

2008 Leaf R&S Rookies Stars #/25 Peyton Manning PSA 10 Black Longevity Refractor

1998 SPx Finite Rookies Peyton Manning #181 Ser#0674/1998 PSA (RC)

1998 Bowman #1 Peyton Manning RC PSA 10 Gem Mint Colts

Peyton Manning Refractor - 2009 Topps Finest #60 - PSA 10 (POP: 20)

1999 Donruss Preferred PEYTON MANNING X-Ponential Power INSERT /2500 PSA 9 HOF

2002 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Black Refractor /599 PSA 9 Mint

Peyton Manning - 1998 Topps Finest RC #121 - Colts Rookie HOF GEM MINT - PSA 10

1998 Collector’s Edge 1st Place Peyton Manning PSA 10 Gem Mint

2014 SP AUTHENTIC #134 PEYTON MANNING BRONCOS HOF PSA 10

1998 Topps Peyton Manning #360 (RC) - PSA 9 MINT 🔥🔥🔥 - Indianapolis Colts

2022 Flawless Peyton Manning Player Worn Patch-Auto PSA 8/PSA 9!!!🔥

2003 Topps Peyton Manning #HM8 Hobby Masters PSA 10 GEM MINT HOF Pop 6

2011 Topps Finest X-Fractor 277/399 Peyton Manning #80 PSA 8 HOF 10p1

2001 Topps Chrome Refractor Peyton Manning #98 Graded PSA 9 /999 Low Pop!

vintage PSA 10 - SUPER BOWL XLI COLTS vs BEARS FULL TICKET - PEYTON MANNING MVP

1998 Topps Finest Peyton Manning Rookie #121 PSA 10 Gem Mint w/ Coating Colts

PEYTON MANNING 2007 TOPPS CHROME COLTS LEGEND REFRACTOR #TC5 PSA 9 MINT