PSA 8
PSA 8 - PEYTON WATSON #/9 Auto - 2022 Leaf Exotic RC Autograph - ZEBRA PRISMATIC
$63
View on eBay →
PSA 10
2013 Panini Prizm Peyton Manning #77 PSA 10
$45
View on eBay →
PSA 10
2001 Pacific Private Stock #66 PEYTON MANNING Game Worn Patch /100 POP 1 PSA 10
$400
View on eBay →
PEYTON MANNING 2001 UPPER DECK GAME WORN USED JERSEY ON CARD AUTO AUTOGRAPH PMAJ
$400
View on eBay →
Peyton Manning 2026 Leaf Football Pay Dirt Comichrome Auto 1/1 Superfractor Colt
$250
View on eBay →
2025 Leaf Metal Halloween Peyton Manning SUPER PRISMATIC GOLD Auto #1/1 - HOF QB
$250
View on eBay →
PSA 10
2009 SP Authentic Ben Roethlisberger Eli Manning Peyton Manning PSA 10 AUTO 1/25
$2,500
View on eBay →
PSA 10
2004 UD Ultimate Peyton Manning Auto Game Jersey Patch 24/25 PSA 10 Dual POP 1
$15,000
View on eBay →
Peyton Manning 2017 Plates And Patches /3 Game Used Auto
$550
View on eBay →
PSA 9
2021 Flawless Peyton Manning Auto Game Worn Jersey Patch /6 PSA 9
$1,999
View on eBay →
PSA 10
1999 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning Stock in the Game Refractor #S12 Colts PSA 10
$89
View on eBay →
PSA 9
1998 peyton Manning Flair showcaee row 1 psa 9
$225
View on eBay →
PSA 9
2000 Collectors Edge Peyton Manning #150 Uncirculated Graded PSA 9 Colts HOF
$18
View on eBay →
PSA 10
2010 Topps Chrome X-Fractor #C50 PEYTON MANNING – PSA 10 GEM MINT!
$140
View on eBay →
PSA 8
1998 Bowman Peyton Manning Gold Rookie PSA 8!! COLTS BRONCOS
$35
View on eBay →
PSA 9
2006 Bowman Chrome Blue Refractor Peyton Manning /150 PSA 9 (pop:4, higher:1)
$160
View on eBay →
PSA 10
2013 PANINI SELECT PEYTON MANNING HOT STARS #12 BRONCOS HOF PSA 10 GEM MINT
$35
View on eBay →
PSA 10
2000 Collector's Edge Masters PEYTON MANNING #/2000 PSA 10
$75
View on eBay →
PSA 10
2008 Upper Deck Heroes Peyton Manning #79 Colts HOF PSA 10
$30
View on eBay →
PSA 10
1999 Stadium Club 3x3 Peyton Manning Illuminator #T4A PSA 10 POP 11 SSP 1:4320
$299
View on eBay →
PSA 9
Peyton Manning 1999 Upper Deck MVP #D10 Dynamics Indianapolis Colts PSA 9
$24
View on eBay →
2007 UltimateCollection Peyton Manning #UM-PE Silver /125 PSA 7
$60
View on eBay →
PSA 8
Peyton Manning (RC) Grade PSA 8 - 1998 Bowman Chrome Rookie #1
$58
View on eBay →
PSA 8
2009 Bowman Chrome #12 Peyton Manning Xfractor /250 PSA 8
$98
View on eBay →
PSA 9
2001 Topps Heritage #25 Peyton Manning PSA 9 MINT; Indianapolis Colts; HOF NFL
$25
View on eBay →
PSA 9
2017 Panini Pantheon Metal #55 Peyton Manning /30 PSA 9 Colts
$103
View on eBay →
1998 TOPPS CHROME #165 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 6
$69
View on eBay →
PSA 9
Peyton Manning 2000 Collector's Edge Uncirculated PSA 9 #150 Indianapolis Colts
$17
View on eBay →
1998 Upper Deck - NFL Star Rookie Peyton Manning #1 (RC) PSA 7
$26
View on eBay →
1998 Score Peyton Manning 1/1 Rookie Auto BGS 8.5 Colts RC Autograph 1 of 1
$3,499
View on eBay →
2019 Panini Flawless Peyton Manning Legends Platinum Diamond #1/1 One of One
$1000
View on eBay →
1999 Finest Peyton Manning Rookie Refractor PSA10 GEM #142
$190
View on eBay →
2006 TOPPS FOOTBALL #51 PEYTON MANNING BLACK BORDER COLTS RARE SP #28/51 PSA 7!
$299
View on eBay →
PSA 10
2024 TOPPS CHROME PEYTON MANNING #H3 HELIX PSA 10
$175
View on eBay →
PSA 9
1999 Flair Showcase #70 PEYTON MANNING PSA 9 Mint Colts
$43
View on eBay →
2000 EX - E-Xceptional Peyton Manning #2 XC Green PSA Colts HOF
$40
View on eBay →
PSA 8
2024 Topps Chrome Legends of the Gridiron Peyton Manning LOG-2 PSA 8
$10
View on eBay →
PSA 10
1998 Collector's Edge Peyton Manning Promo Graded ROOKIE Card PSA 10 Collectors
$86
View on eBay →
PSA 10
Peyton Manning PSA 10 Press Proof Premium 2021 Panini Donruss GEM MINT
$18
View on eBay →
PSA 9
2005 Topps Chrome - Peyton Manning #136 PSA 9
$15
View on eBay →
PSA 10
1998 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning RC #165 PSA 10 💎
$1,450
View on eBay →
PSA 9
2000 Collector's Edge Graded - Peyton Manning #150 PSA 9
$16
View on eBay →
PSA 10
1998 Topps Gold Label - Peyton Manning #20 Class 1 (RC) PSA 10 Gem MINT Card
$320
View on eBay →
PSA 9
1999 Bowman's Best Peyton Manning Refractor #70 PSA 9 /400
$175
View on eBay →
PSA 10
1998 BOWMAN #1 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 10
$260
View on eBay →
PSA 9
1998 Topps Peyton Manning Rookie - PSA 9 - #360
$100
View on eBay →
PSA 9
1998 Upper Deck Black Diamond Rookies Single - PEYTON MANNING - PSA 9 Mint (RC)
$79
View on eBay →
BGS 9.5
Upper Deck 2006 SPx Super Scripts Peyton Manning Colts Auto SS-PM /50 BGS 9.5
$484
View on eBay →
PSA 9
2017 Panini Pantheon Metal #55 Peyton Manning /50 PSA 9 Colts
$103
View on eBay →
PSA 9
1998 Bowman's Best Peyton Manning #112 (RC) - PSA 9 - Mint - Rookie Card
$49
View on eBay →
PSA 10
2011 TOPPS #368 INDIANAPOLIS COLTS PEYTON MANNING PSA 10
$25
View on eBay →
Peyton Manning Signed 5x7 Photo Indianapolis Colts Autographed PSA/DNA COA
$150
View on eBay →
PSA 10
2003 SP Authentic - Sign of the Times Peyton Manning Auto #PM /900 PSA 10/10
$542
View on eBay →
PSA 10
2016 Panini Prestige Peyton Manning Xtra Points Gold /50 #57 PSA GEM MT 10
$85
View on eBay →
PSA 10
Peyton Manning 1998 Collector's Edge Odyssey Holding Jersey Promo RC PSA 10 HOF!
$100
View on eBay →
PSA 8
1998 Upper Deck Encore #1 Peyton Manning PSA 8 Rookie RC Colts Broncos HOF
$70
View on eBay →
PSA 9
PSA 9 1998 98 Bowman Chrome REFRACTOR Preview PEYTON MANNING RC Rookie #BCP1 REF
$385
View on eBay →
PSA 10
2023 Panini Donruss Football Downtown #D9 Peyton Manning PSA 10 GEM SSP
$799
View on eBay →
PSA 10
1998 Topps Finest - Rookie Peyton Manning #121 Rookie RC - PSA 10
$149
View on eBay →
PSA 10
1999 Fleer Tradition PEYTON MANNING Aerial Assault #10 Colts PSA 10
$70
View on eBay →
PSA 9
2011 SCORE #128 PEYTON MANNING COLTS HOF PSA 9
$15
View on eBay →
Peyton Manning 2006 Topps Chrome Black Refractor 108/199 PSA Mint 9
$300
View on eBay →
PSA 8
2003 Topps Draft Picks/Pros Chrome #10 Peyton Manning Gold Refractor PSA 8
$45
View on eBay →
PSA 9
1999 TOPPS CHROME REFRACTOR #120 PEYTON MANNING PSA 9
$225
View on eBay →
PSA 10
1999 Topps Finest - Peyton Manning #1 PSA 10 Colts 2nd Year
$55
View on eBay →
PSA 10
Peyton Manning All-Etch Refractor - 1999 Topps Chrome #AE19 - PSA 10 (POP: 34)
$500
View on eBay →
PSA 10
PEYTON MANNING 2024 SELECT SUITE LEVEL COSMIC PRIZM REFRACTOR PSA 10 *POP 3*
$300
View on eBay →
PSA 9
1998 Topps Finest Peyton Manning #121 Rookie Card RC Indianapolis Colts PSA 9
$60
View on eBay →
PSA 10
Peyton Manning Gold SP /1999 - 1999 Topps Stars of the Game #S9 - PSA 10 (POP 9)
$250
View on eBay →
PSA 9
1998 Topps Stars #67 Gold /1999 Peyton Manning RC PSA 9 Mint Rare Topps Rookie
$250
View on eBay →
PSA 10
2008 UD Heroes Peyton Manning Auto Gold /25 PSA 10 Colts
$1,972
View on eBay →
PSA 9
Collector's Edge 2000 Graded Peyton Manning #150 Uncirculated PSA 9 /5000 Colts
$16
View on eBay →
PSA 9
1998 TOPPS CHROME #165 PEYTON MANNING ROOKIE RC PSA 9
$199
View on eBay →
PSA 10
1999 Bowman Chrome Peyton Manning #70 PSA 10 GEM MINT
$90
View on eBay →
2023 Panini Spectra - Icons Autographs Peyton Manning #I-PM 25/25 (AU)
$323
View on eBay →
Peyton Manning PSA Magazine September 2025 CGC 9.4 SP HOF Colts Broncos Legend
$150
View on eBay →
PSA 9
2021 Contenders To Canton On Card Auto Peyton Manning /20 PSA 9
$300
View on eBay →
PSA 10
2023 Select Peyton Manning Dragon Scale Prizm /70 PSA 10 Gem MINT
$160
View on eBay →
PEYTON MANNING 2008 UPPER DECK MASTERPIECES AUTO PSA SIGNED AUTOGRAPH COLTS
$175
View on eBay →
PSA 8
2000 Bowman Chrome Refractor #112 Peyton Manning PSA 8 (pop:13, higher:26)
$200
View on eBay →
PSA 9
PSA 9 Peyton Manning 1998 TOPPS CHROME ROOKIE RC SP BEAUTIFUL HOF GOAT QB
$200
View on eBay →
PSA 10
2014 SP AUTHENTIC #134 PEYTON MANNING BRONCOS HOF PSA 10
$50
View on eBay →
PSA 8
1999 SP Authentic Player's Ink Green #PMA Peyton Manning PSA 8
$360
View on eBay →
1998 Skybox E-X2001 Peyton Manning RC Rookie #1 Destination Honolulu PSA 6 SSP
$1,087
View on eBay →
1998 Topps Peyton Manning Rookie #360 Colts Rc
$37
View on eBay →
BGS 9
2024 Panini Spectra Spectral Signatures Neon Pink #1 Peyton Manning BGS 9.0
$400
View on eBay →
PSA 9
2000 E-X E-Xceptional Peyton Manning Red PSA 9 Jambalaya Like Insert
$75
View on eBay →
2016 Panini Immaculate Peyton Manning Game Worn /5 PSA Jumbo Patch
$899
View on eBay →
PSA 9
2007 Upper Deck Artifacts Peyton Manning Quad Game Worn Patch 08/10 PSA 9
$325
View on eBay →
PSA 8
GAME USED WORN Peyton Manning/Smith 2005 UD Reflections Dual Jersey Card PSA 8
$100
View on eBay →
2004 UD SPX Peyton Manning Steve McNair Dual Auto Game Worn Patch PSA /25
$850
View on eBay →
1999 Skybox Premium Peyton Manning 2000 Men /100 PSA 6
$1000
View on eBay →
Bowman Autographed Rookie Peyton Manning #1 1998 PSA/DNA 133431536 Colts
$380
View on eBay →
PSA 8
2003 Topps Draft Picks/Pros Chrome #10 Peyton Manning Gold Refractor PSA 8
$40
View on eBay →
PSA 9
2013 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Refractor PSA 9 Broncos
$40
View on eBay →
PSA 10
2024 Topps Cosmic Chrome Planetary Pursuit The Sun Peyton Manning PSA 10
$70
View on eBay →
PSA 10
2016 Panini Prizm Blue Wave /149 Peyton Manning #125 PSA 10 GEM MT HOF READ 8uc
$85
View on eBay →
PSA 10
Peyton Manning 2024 Topps Chrome Auto Gold Wave Refractor #/50 PSA 10 GEM POP 7
$455
View on eBay →
PSA 9
2011 TOPPS PLATINUM #100 PEYTON MANNING COLTS HOF PSA 9
$17
View on eBay →
PSA 10
2000 Skybox Dominion #5 Peyton Manning PSA 10 Characteristics Colts
$200
View on eBay →